328 P.3d 638
Mont.2014Background
- Old-Horn, an inmate in Great Falls Regional Prison, disclosed to his cellmate about prior informant activity and potential immunity in a Mitchell homicide case.
- Gardner contacted two investigators; Lake County Attorney Mitch Young offered immunity for sources’ collateral crimes but not for homicide accountability.
- Old-Horn wrote letters claiming immunity and indicating he would testify about others’ involvement in Mitchell’s death.
- Doyle, Young, and Sargeant interviewed Old-Horn in 2008, read Miranda rights, and Old-Horn signed a waiver, leading to a full confession.
- Two years later, Old-Horn was charged with deliberate homicide; he was questioned again in 2010 without being informed of the charge.
- The District Court suppressed the letters and statements as involuntary, ordering a new trial; the State appealed the suppression order.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the district court erred in ruling Old-Horn’s statements were involuntary | Old-Horn knowingly waived rights; immunity offer was not a coercive promise | Immunity belief induced involuntary waiver and statements | Yes; district court affirmed the suppression and new trial order |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Hoffman, 314 Mont. 155 (2003 MT 26) (voluntariness factors in confession analysis)
- State v. Loh, 914 P.2d 592 (1996 MT) (totality of circumstances; implied promises may render confession involuntary)
- State v. Grimestad, 598 P.2d 198 (1979 MT) (meaningful Miranda warning; downplaying rights can make waiver involuntary)
- State v. Allies, 606 P.2d 1043 (1979 MT) (test for freely, voluntarily given confessions)