State v. McDaniel
254 P.3d 534
| Kan. | 2011Background
- McDaniel pled guilty to aggravated battery stemming from a stabbing in a fight.
- PSI listed Medicaid restitution of $21,269.06; victim and family did not request restitution.
- At sentencing, the court imposed 34 months, the highest presumptive term for severity 5 and history I.
- Restitution amount was discussed; a later hearing was scheduled about the PSI restitution figure.
- McDaniel and State stipulated to a reduced restitution amount of $7,744.26 at the later hearing.
- The issue on appeal included whether restitution proceedings and the subsequent restitution amount affected the sentence.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jurisdiction to set restitution before/after sentencing | McDaniel: hearing must precede sentencing per 22-3424(d). | State: statute is directory; no jurisdictional defect. | Restitution hearing before sentencing not required; statute directory; no jurisdictional defect. |
| Effect of restitution timing on sentence | McDaniel: changing restitution after pronouncement alters sentence improperly. | State: restitution hearing amended amount but did not modify sentence. | No improper sentence modification; restitution completed the sentence, not changed it. |
| Highest grid term under Apprendi | McDaniel: cannot be sentenced to highest term without aggravating facts proved to a jury. | Johnson controls; no reexamination needed. | Affirmed 34-month sentence; Apprendi/Johson reasoning reaffirmed. |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Jackson, 291 Kan. 34 (2010) (sentencing occurs when court pronounces sentence; jurisdictional rules)
- State v. Raschke, 289 Kan. 911 (2009) (directory vs mandatory interpretation factors)
- State v. Bryant, 37 Kan. App. 2d 924 (2007) (K.S.A. 22-3424(d) 'shall' as directory, not mandatory)
- State v. Johnson, 286 Kan. 824 (2008) (Apprendi; highest grid term validity in Kansas)
- State v. Cooper, 267 Kan. 15 (1999) (discretion to extend time to set restitution amount)
