State v. Lutz
2017 Ohio 4077
| Ohio Ct. App. | 2017Background
- Ronald Lutz was convicted by juries in three interrelated Cuyahoga County cases (CR-01-403228-A, CR-01-404605-A, CR-01-405399-A) and sentenced in August 2001 with an entry stating he was to "receive credit for time served."
- Lutz filed a post-sentencing motion (Nov. 16, 2016) seeking jail-time credit for confinement from Feb. 1, 2001 through Aug. 31, 2001 (totaling 212 days), including: Feb. 1–7, 2001 in Lakewood city jail; county jail confinement through Aug. 31, 2001; and Apr. 19–May 17, 2001 at Northcoast Behavioral Center for a court-ordered psychiatric evaluation.
- The trial court granted jail-time credit but awarded only 177 days, excluding the Lakewood jail days and the Northcoast evaluation period.
- The State conceded error in the trial court’s calculation (arguing for 211 days), and Lutz appealed the 177-day award.
- The appellate court reviewed statutory authority for crediting confinement (R.C. 2967.191 and R.C. 2948.38(I)) and relevant precedent construing "confinement" to include institutional stays where a person is not free to come and go.
- The court held the correct total was 212 days and reversed and remanded with instructions to credit Lutz with 212 days.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Lutz is entitled to jail-time credit for all confinement from Feb. 1–Aug. 31, 2001, including time in Lakewood city jail and a court-ordered psychiatric evaluation at Northcoast | State concedes trial court miscalculated; suggests 211 days | Lutz contends he is entitled to 212 days (Feb. 1–Aug. 31, 2001), including Lakewood and Northcoast periods | Court held Lutz is entitled to 212 days of jail-time credit and reversed the 177-day award |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Napier, 93 Ohio St.3d 646 (2001) ("Confinement" includes stays in institutions or programs where the person is not free to come and go)
