242 P.3d 954
Wash. Ct. App.2010Background
- At a bench trial on stipulated facts, Louthan was found guilty of unlawful possession of methamphetamine under RCW 69.50.4013(1).
- Louthan appeals contending the arrest lacked probable cause to arrest for possession of drug paraphernalia and that the suppression motion should have been granted.
- Officer Hayden stopped Louthan on a closed portion of Highway 107; he suspected DUI in violation of former RCW 46.61.502, based on observed conduct and impairment indicators.
- Hayden observed what appeared to be drug paraphernalia (an orange juice container bong) behind Louthan’s seat during the stop and arrested him.
- A vehicle search yielded a black tar residue, three bindles with powder (methamphetamine), a blade with tar, two glass pipes, and a digital scale; tests and later lab confirmation identified methamphetamine and heroin.
- Louthan moved to suppress the evidence; the trial court denied, and the issue on appeal centers on the legality of the arrest and the vehicle search.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Probable cause for arrest | Louthan asserts no probable cause for arrest. | Hayden relied on a local ordinance; argues lack of probable cause under state law. | Arrest for driving under the influence of a controlled substance supported probable cause. |
| Preservation of the search issue | Louthan preserved only the arrest issue, not the search scope. | State should be able to defend the search on any valid grounds. | Louthan failed to preserve an objection to the scope of the search; review of the search is limited. |
| Application of Gant/Patton/Valdez to the search | Patton and Valdez limit warrantless searches for evidence of the crime of arrest. | Gant/Snapp support searching for evidence of the arrest crime in the vehicle. | Gant applies; Patton and Valdez do not bar the search under the facts; the search was lawful for evidence of the arrest crime. |
| Open-view seizure and exigent circumstances | Open-view seizure requires exigent circumstances or a warrant. | Open-view seizure permitted the bong’s seizure; flooding/closure created exigency. | Open-view seizure upheld; exigent circumstances existed; seizure of the bong was permissible. |
Key Cases Cited
- Gaines v. State, 154 Wn.2d 711 (2005) (recognizes warrant requirement and open-view principles in Washington)
- State v. Gaddy, 152 Wn.2d 64 (2004) (probable cause in arrest determinations; standard applied)
- State v. McKenna, 91 Wn. App. 554 (1998) (probable cause standard for arrest visits)
- State v. Vrieling, 144 Wn.2d 489 (2001) (search incident to arrest; scope and authority guidance)
- State v. Huff, 64 Wn. App. 641 (1992) (arrest supported by probable cause not nullified by later grounds)
- State v. Snapp, 153 Wn. App. 485 (2009) (Gant-based justification for vehicle search for evidence of arrest crime)
- Arizona v. Gant, 556 U.S. 332 (2009) (limitations on searches of vehicles incident to arrest)
- State v. Patton, 167 Wn.2d 379 (2009) (state constitutional framing of vehicle searches incident to arrest)
- State v. Valdez, 167 Wn.2d 761 (2009) (scope of vehicle search incident to arrest; application to Arrestee proximity)
- State v. Winterstein, 167 Wn.2d 620 (2009) (probable cause determinations are objective inquiries)
- State v. Afana, 169 Wn.2d 169 (2010) (exclusionary rule and state constitution application; developments)