midpage
242 P.3d 954
Wash. Ct. App.
2010

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • At a bench trial on stipulated facts, Louthan was found guilty of unlawful possession of methamphetamine under RCW 69.50.4013(1).
  • Louthan appeals contending the arrest lacked probable cause to arrest for possession of drug paraphernalia and that the suppression motion should have been granted.
  • Officer Hayden stopped Louthan on a closed portion of Highway 107; he suspected DUI in violation of former RCW 46.61.502, based on observed conduct and impairment indicators.
  • Hayden observed what appeared to be drug paraphernalia (an orange juice container bong) behind Louthan’s seat during the stop and arrested him.
  • A vehicle search yielded a black tar residue, three bindles with powder (methamphetamine), a blade with tar, two glass pipes, and a digital scale; tests and later lab confirmation identified methamphetamine and heroin.
  • Louthan moved to suppress the evidence; the trial court denied, and the issue on appeal centers on the legality of the arrest and the vehicle search.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Probable cause for arrest Louthan asserts no probable cause for arrest. Hayden relied on a local ordinance; argues lack of probable cause under state law. Arrest for driving under the influence of a controlled substance supported probable cause.
Preservation of the search issue Louthan preserved only the arrest issue, not the search scope. State should be able to defend the search on any valid grounds. Louthan failed to preserve an objection to the scope of the search; review of the search is limited.
Application of Gant/Patton/Valdez to the search Patton and Valdez limit warrantless searches for evidence of the crime of arrest. Gant/Snapp support searching for evidence of the arrest crime in the vehicle. Gant applies; Patton and Valdez do not bar the search under the facts; the search was lawful for evidence of the arrest crime.
Open-view seizure and exigent circumstances Open-view seizure requires exigent circumstances or a warrant. Open-view seizure permitted the bong’s seizure; flooding/closure created exigency. Open-view seizure upheld; exigent circumstances existed; seizure of the bong was permissible.

Key Cases Cited

  • Gaines v. State, 154 Wn.2d 711 (2005) (recognizes warrant requirement and open-view principles in Washington)
  • State v. Gaddy, 152 Wn.2d 64 (2004) (probable cause in arrest determinations; standard applied)
  • State v. McKenna, 91 Wn. App. 554 (1998) (probable cause standard for arrest visits)
  • State v. Vrieling, 144 Wn.2d 489 (2001) (search incident to arrest; scope and authority guidance)
  • State v. Huff, 64 Wn. App. 641 (1992) (arrest supported by probable cause not nullified by later grounds)
  • State v. Snapp, 153 Wn. App. 485 (2009) (Gant-based justification for vehicle search for evidence of arrest crime)
  • Arizona v. Gant, 556 U.S. 332 (2009) (limitations on searches of vehicles incident to arrest)
  • State v. Patton, 167 Wn.2d 379 (2009) (state constitutional framing of vehicle searches incident to arrest)
  • State v. Valdez, 167 Wn.2d 761 (2009) (scope of vehicle search incident to arrest; application to Arrestee proximity)
  • State v. Winterstein, 167 Wn.2d 620 (2009) (probable cause determinations are objective inquiries)
  • State v. Afana, 169 Wn.2d 169 (2010) (exclusionary rule and state constitution application; developments)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Louthan
Court Name: Court of Appeals of Washington
Date Published: Nov 30, 2010
Citations: 242 P.3d 954; 158 Wash. App. 732; No. 38472-8-II
Docket Number: No. 38472-8-II
Court Abbreviation: Wash. Ct. App.
Log In