State v. Kelly
244 P.3d 639
| Kan. | 2010Background
- In 1994, Kelly, age 14, killed a liquor-store clerk during a robbery and was charged with first-degree felony murder and aggravated robbery.
- The juvenile court waived jurisdiction, certifying Kelly for adult prosecution, and he pleaded guilty to both charges with counsel.
- Sentencing: life for felony murder and a consecutive 172-month term for aggravated robbery, despite a proposed downward durational departure and juxtapositions of sentences.
- On August 30, 2007, Kelly, pro se, filed a motion to withdraw plea and to correct illegal sentence and to vacate sentence, with an 11-page memorandum alleging ineffective assistance of counsel among other claims.
- The district court denied the motion, construed it as a K.S.A. 60-1507 claim, and held it untimely; no hearing was held.
- On appeal, Kelly argued the motion should be treated as a motion to withdraw his plea under K.S.A. 22-3210(d).
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the motion should be construed as a withdrawal of plea | Kelly: pleadings should be read as motion to withdraw plea | State: proper framing was ineffective-assistance under 60-1507 | Yes; construed as motion to withdraw plea. |
| Which statute governs pre/post-sentencing withdrawal | Kelly entitles relief under pre-sentencing standard | State: 60-1507 governs if treated as such | Pre-amendment standard applies; remand needed. |
| Proper disposition on remand | Kelly seeks manifest injustice review for withdrawal | State: no manifest injustice shown | Remand to consider manifest injustice under 22-3210. |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Aguilar, 290 Kan. 506 (2010) (guidance on withdrawal and related standards)
- Bruner v. State, 277 Kan. 603 (2004) (liberal construction of pro se pleadings)
- Estate of Draper v. Bank of America, 288 Kan. 510 (2009) (construction of written instruments; legal standards on pleadings)
- State v. Edwards, 290 Kan. 330 (2010) (premature application of amended 22-3210 guidance)
