History
  • No items yet
midpage
191 A.3d 1181
Me.
2018
Read the full case

Background

  • Police executed a search warrant at an Augusta residence and found illegal drugs; a resident (cooperating individual) identified his supplier as a black male known as "Troy," who would deliver ~10 grams of heroin that evening.
  • The cooperating individual produced text messages corroborating that the delivery was "good to go," and said the supplier would be driving a blue BMW SUV from the Portland area and often transported heroin in his pants.
  • Officers positioned around the neighborhood observed a blue BMW SUV with a black male driver and white passenger drive along a likely route from Portland and then turn onto the short dead‑end street by the residence.
  • The detective initiated a traffic stop as the blue BMW approached the residence; Journet (the driver) was ordered out, patted down, handcuffed, taken to the sheriff’s office, and later confessed; the passenger produced a baggie containing nearly ten grams of heroin.
  • Journet moved to suppress the heroin and his statements, arguing the warrantless arrest lacked probable cause; the motion court denied suppression, and the trial court accepted a conditional guilty plea to aggravated trafficking (Class A). The Maine Law Court affirmed.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether officers had probable cause to effect a warrantless arrest of Journet Journet: officers lacked probable cause; arrest was unlawful so statements and evidence should be suppressed State: collective, corroborated information (search results, tip, texts, vehicle/time/route match) gave probable cause to arrest for felony trafficking Court held: probable cause existed based on the totality of corroborated information; suppression denied
Reliability of the cooperating individual/tip as basis for arrest Journet: tipster was untested by police and therefore unreliable State: tipster’s information was substantially corroborated (drugs at the house, texts, vehicle, timing, route), supplying sufficient indicia of reliability Court held: corroboration rendered the tip reliable enough to support probable cause

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Kierstead, 114 A.3d 984 (Me. 2015) (standard for appellate review of motion‑to‑suppress findings when no request for further findings)
  • State v. Lagasse, 149 A.3d 1153 (Me. 2016) (probable cause standard for warrantless arrests; collective knowledge rule)
  • State v. Parkinson, 389 A.2d 1 (Me. 1978) (definition of probable cause)
  • Maryland v. Pringle, 540 U.S. 366 (U.S. 2003) (probable cause can be based on facts warranting belief a felony was committed by occupants of a vehicle)
  • State v. Carr, 704 A.2d 353 (Me. 1997) (collective information known to police may support probable cause)
  • State v. Enggass, 571 A.2d 823 (Me. 1990) (objective examination of facts known to officers for probable cause)
  • State v. Heald, 314 A.2d 820 (Me. 1973) (probable cause analysis framework)
  • State v. Violette, 138 A.3d 491 (Me. 2016) (reasonable suspicion standard for investigatory stops)
  • State v. Commeau, 852 A.2d 70 (Me. 2004) (tactical considerations about requesting further findings after an adverse ruling)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Journet
Court Name: Supreme Judicial Court of Maine
Date Published: Aug 14, 2018
Citations: 191 A.3d 1181; 2018 ME 114; Docket: Ken-17-492
Docket Number: Docket: Ken-17-492
Court Abbreviation: Me.
Log In
    State v. Journet, 191 A.3d 1181