History
  • No items yet
midpage
351 Conn. 324
Conn.
2025
Read the full case

Background

  • Brandon Jones was convicted of murder in connection with the 2005 shooting death of Dante Davis in Hartford, Connecticut.
  • The prosecution argued the shooting was motivated by an ongoing feud between two street gangs, "The Ave" (with which Jones was allegedly affiliated) and "West Hell."
  • Evidence linking Jones to the gang and indicating motive came from multiple police and witness testimonies about the group affiliations and the context of neighborhood violence.
  • After more than 16 years without charges, Jones was arrested in Texas following tips from two incarcerated witnesses.
  • Jones appealed his conviction, arguing the trial court erred by admitting evidence of his alleged gang affiliation and his actions after law enforcement attempted to arrest him in Louisiana, claiming prejudice and lack of relevance.

Issues

Issue Appellant's Argument State's Argument Held
Admission of gang affiliation evidence Jones: Irrelevant and highly prejudicial; no established link to the crime State: Relevant to establish motive; linked feud explains shooting Properly admitted; probative outweighs prejudice
Admission of post-arrest attempt conduct (consciousness of guilt) Jones: Conduct too remote from crime; not indicative of guilt State: Evasive conduct occurred right after learning of warrant; shows guilt Properly admitted as probative evidence

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Bermudez, 341 Conn. 233 (evidence of gang affiliation is admissible to show motive or bias if its probative value outweighs prejudicial risk)
  • State v. Wilson, 308 Conn. 412 (gang evidence properly admitted to establish motive for killing)
  • State v. Taylor, 239 Conn. 481 (gang evidence used to establish motive and permissible with proper limiting instruction)
  • State v. Hill, 307 Conn. 689 (consciousness of guilt evidence is admissible if relevant and more probative than prejudicial)
  • State v. Oliveras, 210 Conn. 751 (flight and evasive action are classic forms of consciousness of guilt evidence)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Jones
Court Name: Supreme Court of Connecticut
Date Published: Feb 25, 2025
Citations: 351 Conn. 324; 330 A.3d 118; SC20840
Docket Number: SC20840
Court Abbreviation: Conn.
Log In
    State v. Jones, 351 Conn. 324