History
  • No items yet
midpage
State v. Huddleston
298 Kan. 941
| Kan. | 2014
Read the full case

Background

  • Huddleston was convicted of premeditated first-degree murder for Todd Stover’s 2000 death.
  • Two prosecutors argued premeditation could occur after the killing, which the court found to be misstatements of law.
  • The trial admitted two jailhouse letters Huddleston wrote to her sister, implicating her in the death and shifting blame.
  • Evidence included Huddleston’s statements to police, her plan to kill Stover with insulin, and her actions before, during, and after the killing.
  • The court held the misstatements were harmless under Tosh and upheld the conviction, and also held the jailhouse letters admissible as probative of consciousness of guilt and intent.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Was prosecutorial misconduct reversible? Huddleston Huddleston No reversible error; misconduct was harmless
Are the jailhouse letters admissible and probative? Huddleston Huddleston Admissible; letters probative of intent/consciousness of guilt outweigh prejudice

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Henry, 273 Kan. 608 (2002) (misstated law considered with jury instructions and other error)
  • State v. Moncla, 262 Kan. 58 (1997) (misstatements evaluated under harmless error framework)
  • State v. Tosh, 278 Kan. 83 (2004) (two-step prosecutorial-misconduct analysis; harmlessness under Tosh standard)
  • State v. Bridges, 297 Kan. 989 (2013) (dual harmlessness standard; constitutional and statutory harmlessness applied)
  • State v. Herbel, 296 Kan. 1101 (2013) (distinguishes程度 of harmlessness for constitutional error)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Huddleston
Court Name: Supreme Court of Kansas
Date Published: Feb 14, 2014
Citation: 298 Kan. 941
Docket Number: No. 106,273
Court Abbreviation: Kan.