563 P.3d 890
N.M.2024Background
- Donovan Houidobre ("Prisoner") completed two substance abuse programs (TC and RDAP) in a New Mexico private correctional facility and sought a thirty-day lump-sum meritorious deduction (LSA) for each completion.
- The New Mexico Corrections Department (NMCD) granted an LSA for the first program but denied one for RDAP, claiming policy prohibits more than one LSA for "identical" programs.
- NMCD regulations expressly prohibited prisoner appeals of LSA denials.
- Six years later, Houidobre filed a habeas petition, arguing that the denial of the second LSA, without opportunity for appeal, violated his procedural due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment.
- The district court granted habeas relief, ordering the thirty-day LSA, and the State appealed the decision to the New Mexico Supreme Court.
- The Court addressed whether NMCD’s denial and prohibition of review constituted a due process violation given the statutory provisions of the Earned Meritorious Deductions Act (EMDA).
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Does completion of an approved program create a constitutionally protected liberty interest in LSA eligibility? | Houidobre: Completion creates entitlement to award. | State: No liberty interest; NMCD has discretion. | Yes, eligibility for consideration is a liberty interest, not entitlement to award. |
| Did NMCD's policy barring appeals of denial violate due process? | Denial without review is arbitrary and unconstitutional. | NMCD's discretion precludes any due process right to review. | Yes, denying any opportunity to be heard violates due process. |
| Was denial of LSA for RDAP arbitrary under NMCD rules and EMDA? | No rule prohibits LSAs for both TC and RDAP; denial was unsupported. | Both programs are "identical." Only one LSA allowed by policy. | No valid rule barred both LSAs; denial was arbitrary and violated due process. |
| Was the district court's remedy of ordering the LSA proper? | Court should restore the 30-day LSA directly. | District court cannot award LSA; must allow NMCD review. | Remedy was appropriate due to NMCD's procedural deficiency barring appeals. |
Key Cases Cited
- Wolff v. McDonnell, 418 U.S. 539 (rules for procedural due process in prison good time credit cases)
- Board of Pardons v. Allen, 482 U.S. 369 (mandatory statutory language can create a liberty interest)
- Carey v. Piphus, 435 U.S. 247 (due process protects against arbitrary deprivation of liberty)
- Mathews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S. 319 (test for adequacy of administrative procedures under due process)
- Superintendent, Mass. Corr. Inst., Walpole v. Hill, 472 U.S. 445 (due process violation if governmental decision is unsupported by evidence)
- Brooks v. Shanks, 118 N.M. 716 (New Mexico law on due process and forfeiture of good time credit)