midpage
563 P.3d 890
N.M.
2024

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Donovan Houidobre ("Prisoner") completed two substance abuse programs (TC and RDAP) in a New Mexico private correctional facility and sought a thirty-day lump-sum meritorious deduction (LSA) for each completion.
  • The New Mexico Corrections Department (NMCD) granted an LSA for the first program but denied one for RDAP, claiming policy prohibits more than one LSA for "identical" programs.
  • NMCD regulations expressly prohibited prisoner appeals of LSA denials.
  • Six years later, Houidobre filed a habeas petition, arguing that the denial of the second LSA, without opportunity for appeal, violated his procedural due process rights under the Fourteenth Amendment.
  • The district court granted habeas relief, ordering the thirty-day LSA, and the State appealed the decision to the New Mexico Supreme Court.
  • The Court addressed whether NMCD’s denial and prohibition of review constituted a due process violation given the statutory provisions of the Earned Meritorious Deductions Act (EMDA).

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Does completion of an approved program create a constitutionally protected liberty interest in LSA eligibility? Houidobre: Completion creates entitlement to award. State: No liberty interest; NMCD has discretion. Yes, eligibility for consideration is a liberty interest, not entitlement to award.
Did NMCD's policy barring appeals of denial violate due process? Denial without review is arbitrary and unconstitutional. NMCD's discretion precludes any due process right to review. Yes, denying any opportunity to be heard violates due process.
Was denial of LSA for RDAP arbitrary under NMCD rules and EMDA? No rule prohibits LSAs for both TC and RDAP; denial was unsupported. Both programs are "identical." Only one LSA allowed by policy. No valid rule barred both LSAs; denial was arbitrary and violated due process.
Was the district court's remedy of ordering the LSA proper? Court should restore the 30-day LSA directly. District court cannot award LSA; must allow NMCD review. Remedy was appropriate due to NMCD's procedural deficiency barring appeals.

Key Cases Cited

  • Wolff v. McDonnell, 418 U.S. 539 (rules for procedural due process in prison good time credit cases)
  • Board of Pardons v. Allen, 482 U.S. 369 (mandatory statutory language can create a liberty interest)
  • Carey v. Piphus, 435 U.S. 247 (due process protects against arbitrary deprivation of liberty)
  • Mathews v. Eldridge, 424 U.S. 319 (test for adequacy of administrative procedures under due process)
  • Superintendent, Mass. Corr. Inst., Walpole v. Hill, 472 U.S. 445 (due process violation if governmental decision is unsupported by evidence)
  • Brooks v. Shanks, 118 N.M. 716 (New Mexico law on due process and forfeiture of good time credit)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Houidobre
Court Name: New Mexico Supreme Court
Date Published: Nov 18, 2024
Citations: 563 P.3d 890; 2025-NMSC-007
Court Abbreviation: N.M.
Log In