State v. Hidalgo
296 Neb. 912
| Neb. | 2017Background
- Crime Stoppers anonymous tip (July 10, 2015) reported a Hispanic male "Roberto" (nicknamed "Sporty"), an 18th Street gang member, was a felon in possession of illegal firearms and lived at a specific Omaha address.
- Police surveilled the address, observed several tattooed Hispanic men on the porch, and noted a white Nissan Sentra registered to Robert Hidalgo and Jacqueline Linares in the driveway.
- Officers’ checks showed utilities in Linares’s name; Hidalgo (born 1987) was identified by gang investigators as an 18th Street gang member with nickname “Shorty.”
- A trash pull from the property produced mail for the address and marijuana stems/seeds/leaves.
- Based on the tip and investigative corroboration, officers obtained and executed a search warrant for the residence; officers found firearms inside the house, a firearm in a neighboring yard, and a firearm inside the Nissan Sentra. Hidalgo later admitted the gun in the car was his.
- Hidalgo (a convicted accessory to a felony) was charged, convicted after a stipulated bench trial of possession of a firearm by a prohibited person, and sentenced to 3–5 years; he appealed, arguing lack of probable cause and improper vehicle search.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Probable cause for search warrant | State: affidavit and corroboration (vehicle registration, utilities, trash pull, officers’ observations) supported probable cause | Hidalgo: anonymous tip unreliable; corroboration only established innocent details; trash marijuana insufficient | Court: Probable cause existed under totality of circumstances; corroboration and trash evidence plus tip supported issuance of warrant; conviction affirmed |
| Scope of warrant — vehicle search | State: vehicle on premises may be searched as part of warrant scope; affidavit connected vehicle to occupants and referenced vehicles in gang/narcotics context | Hidalgo: warrant described house only; vehicle not listed, so search of Sentra exceeded warrant | Court: Vehicle in driveway contiguous to house fell within warrant scope; affidavit contemplated vehicles; search valid |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Hill, 288 Neb. 767 (discussing probable cause and review standard for warrants)
- Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213 (establishing totality-of-the-circumstances test for informant tips)
- State v. Vermuele, 234 Neb. 973 (no requirement that alleged crime itself be independently corroborated)
- U.S. v. Pennington, 287 F.3d 739 (8th Cir.) (vehicle on premises may fall within the scope of a residence search warrant)
