265 P.3d 185
Wash. Ct. App.2011Background
- Hawkins convicted of first-degree murder in 1987 with an exceptional sentence of 600 months minimum and life maximum, based on three aggravating factors.
- 1989 Division Two affirmed and modified the sentence language without remanding for resentencing.
- Hawkins pursued multiple postconviction petitions and motions over the years, including CrR 8.3 and CrR 7.8(b) proceedings.
- In 2010 Hawkins sought an amendment to conform judgment to the 1989 Court of Appeals decision, resulting in a ministerial hearing before Judge Warning.
- At the May 7, 2010 hearing Hawkins argued, among other things, for Judge Warning’s recusal; Judge Warning denied recusal and signed the ministerial correction order.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Authority of visiting judge | Holmes required record of request for visiting judge. | Record need not show visiting judge request; authority presumed. | Presumed authority; Holmes controls; record need not show request. |
| Recusal timeliness | Judge Warning erred in not recusing after prejudice affidavit. | Motion untimely; no demonstrated prejudice. | Untimely affidavit; no prejudice shown; no reversal. |
| Right to counsel at ministerial hearing | Indigent Hawkins had right to counsel at all proceedings. | Ministerial correction hearing not a critical stage; no right to counsel. | No right to counsel; hearing not a critical stage. |
| Apprendi/Blakely retroactivity | Apprendi/Blakely entitle postconviction relief and remand. | Res judicata bars; not retroactive on collateral review. | Res judicata bars; not retroactive on collateral review. |
| Additional grounds raised | Restates CrR 8.3/7.8 claims already litigated. | Claims barred by res judicata. | Res judicata bars reassertion; affirmed. |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Holmes, 12 Wash. 169 (1895) (visiting judge authority without explicit record affirmed)
- State v. Belgarde, 119 Wash.2d 711 (1992) (retrial/continuation under RCW 4.12.050 considerations)
- State v. Waters, 93 Wash.App. 969 (1999) (prejudice standards under CrR 4.12)
- State v. Cockrell, 102 Wash.2d 561 (1984) (prejudice standards; disqualification effects)
- State v. Valentine, 132 Wash.2d 1 (1997) (constitutional right to counsel in certain contexts)
- In re Pers. Restraint of Gentry, 137 Wash.2d 378 (1999) (indigent counsel; postconviction proceedings feasibility)
- State v. Evans, 154 Wash.2d 438 (2005) (retroactivity of Apprendi/Blakely on collateral review)