midpage
265 P.3d 185
Wash. Ct. App.
2011
Read the full case

Background

  • Hawkins convicted of first-degree murder in 1987 with an exceptional sentence of 600 months minimum and life maximum, based on three aggravating factors.
  • 1989 Division Two affirmed and modified the sentence language without remanding for resentencing.
  • Hawkins pursued multiple postconviction petitions and motions over the years, including CrR 8.3 and CrR 7.8(b) proceedings.
  • In 2010 Hawkins sought an amendment to conform judgment to the 1989 Court of Appeals decision, resulting in a ministerial hearing before Judge Warning.
  • At the May 7, 2010 hearing Hawkins argued, among other things, for Judge Warning’s recusal; Judge Warning denied recusal and signed the ministerial correction order.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Authority of visiting judge Holmes required record of request for visiting judge. Record need not show visiting judge request; authority presumed. Presumed authority; Holmes controls; record need not show request.
Recusal timeliness Judge Warning erred in not recusing after prejudice affidavit. Motion untimely; no demonstrated prejudice. Untimely affidavit; no prejudice shown; no reversal.
Right to counsel at ministerial hearing Indigent Hawkins had right to counsel at all proceedings. Ministerial correction hearing not a critical stage; no right to counsel. No right to counsel; hearing not a critical stage.
Apprendi/Blakely retroactivity Apprendi/Blakely entitle postconviction relief and remand. Res judicata bars; not retroactive on collateral review. Res judicata bars; not retroactive on collateral review.
Additional grounds raised Restates CrR 8.3/7.8 claims already litigated. Claims barred by res judicata. Res judicata bars reassertion; affirmed.

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Holmes, 12 Wash. 169 (1895) (visiting judge authority without explicit record affirmed)
  • State v. Belgarde, 119 Wash.2d 711 (1992) (retrial/continuation under RCW 4.12.050 considerations)
  • State v. Waters, 93 Wash.App. 969 (1999) (prejudice standards under CrR 4.12)
  • State v. Cockrell, 102 Wash.2d 561 (1984) (prejudice standards; disqualification effects)
  • State v. Valentine, 132 Wash.2d 1 (1997) (constitutional right to counsel in certain contexts)
  • In re Pers. Restraint of Gentry, 137 Wash.2d 378 (1999) (indigent counsel; postconviction proceedings feasibility)
  • State v. Evans, 154 Wash.2d 438 (2005) (retroactivity of Apprendi/Blakely on collateral review)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Hawkins
Court Name: Court of Appeals of Washington
Date Published: Nov 7, 2011
Citations: 265 P.3d 185; 164 Wash. App. 705; 66936-2-I
Docket Number: 66936-2-I
Court Abbreviation: Wash. Ct. App.
Log In