State v. Glaser
2015 ND 31
| N.D. | 2015Background
- Glaser pled guilty to indecent exposure, after initially pleading not guilty.
- District court sentenced him to one year with nine months suspended and placed him on two years’ probation, and ordered registration as a sex offender.
- Glaser challenged registration, arguing no prior sex-offense history, no mental abnormality or predatory conduct, and non-minor victim.
- A statutory dispute arose over which definition of predatory conduct controls for registration: §12.1-32-15(1)(d) vs §25-03.3-01(9).
- The district court applied §12.1-32-15(1)(d) and required registration, citing the stranger-directed predatory conduct standard.
- Pre-sentencing, Dr. Ascano prepared a psychosexual risk assessment; the court considered it but was not required to grant relief from registration.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Which predatory conduct definition governs registration? | State: §12.1-32-15(1)(d) controls. | Glaser: §25-03.3-01(9) controls. | §12.1-32-15(1)(d) governs predatory conduct for registration. |
| Did the court abuse discretion by requiring registration despite discretionary factors and the risk assessment? | State: discretion exists but court could require registration. | Glaser: court should have considered risk assessment to excuse registration. | Court did not abuse discretion; could consider but was not required to deviate. |
| Was there obvious error under Rule 11(b)(3) for a lack of factual basis for the guilty plea? | State: no issue raised. | Glaser: insufficient factual basis for plea. | District court had a sufficient factual basis; no obvious Rule 11(b)(3) error. |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Wardner, 2006 ND 256 (ND 2006) (sentencing review standard; statute limits and permissible factors)
- State v. Corman, 2009 ND 85 (ND 2009) (predatory conduct definition for registration contextualized)
- Mackey v. State, 2012 ND 159 (ND 2012) (establishes factual-basis method for Rule 11(b)(3))
- State v. Holbach, 2014 ND 14 (ND 2014) (statutory interpretation guidelines and application)
