History
  • No items yet
midpage
State v. Gach
297 Neb. 96
Neb.
2017
Read the full case

Background

  • In 2010 Buoy P. Gach pleaded no contest to first-degree assault; other charges dismissed; he was sentenced to 10–20 years’ imprisonment.
  • At the plea hearing the court did not recite the verbatim statutory immigration advisement (§ 29-1819.02(1)); it told Gach his immigration status "could be affected" and he "could be deported."
  • Gach is not a U.S. citizen. In April 2010 ICE filed an immigration detainer instructing the Department of Correctional Services (DCS) to hold Gach so DHS could assume custody to determine removability.
  • In 2014 Gach moved to vacate his conviction and withdraw his plea under § 29-1819.02(2), arguing the court failed to give the required advisement of immigration consequences.
  • The district court found the court had not given the verbatim advisement (first Yos‑Chiguil factor satisfied) but concluded Gach was warned he could be deported/removal (second factor failed) and denied the motion; Gach appealed.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether failure to give the verbatim § 29‑1819.02(1) advisement requires vacatur and plea withdrawal Gach: court did not give the statutory advisement, so under § 29‑1819.02(2) his conviction must be vacated because he faces immigration consequences State: substantial compliance or the colloquy warned of deportation/removal, so remedy is not warranted Court: First prong met (advisement not verbatim); second prong failed—Gach showed he faces removal but did not prove the court failed to communicate that consequence; motion denied, judgment affirmed

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Yos-Chiguil, 278 Neb. 591 (2009) (establishes two‑part test for § 29‑1819.02 relief)
  • State v. Mena-Rivera, 280 Neb. 948 (2010) (ICE detainer establishes that defendant "actually faces" immigration consequences)
  • State v. Rodriguez, 288 Neb. 714 (2014) (admonition that courts should use the precise statutory advisement language)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Gach
Court Name: Nebraska Supreme Court
Date Published: Jun 30, 2017
Citation: 297 Neb. 96
Docket Number: S-16-156
Court Abbreviation: Neb.