405 P.3d 1194
Kan.2017Background
- In 1990 Tyrence Lee Buford pled guilty to felony murder and was sentenced to life imprisonment under K.S.A. 21-4501(a).
- Buford has appeared before the Kansas Parole Board multiple times and was repeatedly denied parole; his most recent denial was alleged in 2014.
- In November 2014 Buford filed a pro se K.S.A. 22-3504 motion to correct an illegal sentence, arguing each parole denial amounted to a new, illegal sentence.
- Buford contended the parole denials relied on an improper classification of his pre-1993 prior conviction under the Kansas Sentencing Guidelines, raising Sixth Amendment concerns (citing Descamps and Dickey).
- The district court summarily denied the motion, finding Buford received a proper life sentence; Buford appealed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether a parole denial constitutes an illegal "sentence" under K.S.A. 22-3504 | Buford: each parole "pass" constituted a new sentence increasing his penalty based on misclassified prior conviction | State: parole denials are not sentences; underlying sentence remains life imprisonment | The denial of parole is not a sentence; 22-3504 does not apply; district court affirmed |
Key Cases Cited
- Descamps v. United States, 570 U.S. 254 (Supreme Court rule on Sixth Amendment and prior-conviction enhancements)
- State v. Dickey, 301 Kan. 1018 (Kan. 2015) (application of Descamps principles in Kansas)
- Gilmore v. Kansas Parole Board, 243 Kan. 173 (prisoner has no liberty interest in parole grant)
- State v. Gilbert, 299 Kan. 797 (standard of review for summary denial of 22-3504 motions)
- State v. Gray, 303 Kan. 1011 (definition of an illegal sentence under 22-3504)
- Battrick v. State, 267 Kan. 389 (requirement to exhaust administrative remedies before 60-1501 relief)
