STATE OF NEW JERSEY VS. DARRYL J. HUNTER (15-02-0132, UNION COUNTY AND STATEWIDE)
A-2641-15T3
| N.J. Super. Ct. App. Div. | May 31, 2017Background
- At ~8:30 p.m., Elizabeth police received an anonymous tip describing a bearded Black male in a gray hooded sweatshirt and khaki pants waving a handgun on Community Lane.
- Sgt. Kelly arrived within two minutes, stopped half a block away on a well-lit corner, and observed a white Pontiac pass slowly about three feet from his patrol car. He clearly saw the driver: a bearded Black male in a gray hoodie.
- Kelly performed a traffic stop based on the match between the tip and his observations; the driver (Hunter) ducked after the car stopped and then opened the door when approached.
- Officers saw a loaded magazine on the driver-side floor and recovered a semi-automatic handgun under the passenger seat; Hunter was arrested and later made post-Miranda statements admitting possession.
- The vehicle owner (Hunter’s girlfriend) consented to a further search, which yielded suspected cocaine and a scale.
- Hunter moved to suppress, arguing the stop lacked reasonable and articulable suspicion because the anonymous tip was not independently corroborated; the trial court denied the motion and Hunter pleaded guilty to weapons and terroristic-threats charges.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the warrantless stop of the Pontiac was supported by reasonable and articulable suspicion | Police contended the tip plus Kelly’s immediate, close-range observation of a person matching the tip near the reported location within minutes gave specific, corroborative facts justifying the stop | Hunter argued the anonymous tip alone was insufficient and police failed to independently corroborate criminal activity to justify the stop | The court affirmed: under the totality of circumstances, the close temporal and spatial proximity and the officer’s ability to observe identifying details provided reasonable and articulable suspicion for the stop |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Privott, 203 N.J. 16 (discusses limits of anonymous tips and need for corroboration)
- State v. Gamble, 218 N.J. 412 (totality-of-circumstances test for reasonable suspicion)
- State v. Maryland, 167 N.J. 471 (officer may draw reasonable inferences from observed facts)
- State v. Carty, 170 N.J. 632 (automobile stop must be supported by reasonable and articulable suspicion)
- Florida v. J.L., 529 U.S. 266 (anonymous tip alleging a firearm, without corroboration, insufficient for stop/search)
- State v. Elders, 192 N.J. 224 (deferential appellate review of suppression findings)
