STATE ex rel. OKLAHOMA BAR ASSOCIATION v. FOARD
2017 OK 92
| Okla. | 2017Background
- Jean Lea Foard, OBA #19659, submitted a resignation from the Oklahoma Bar Association on August 26, 2017, while under investigation in grievance DC 17-74.
- Grievance DC 17-74 alleged Foard misappropriated or converted settlement funds received on behalf of two minor children.
- Foard executed an affidavit supporting her resignation, waiving her right to contest the alleged misconduct.
- The Bar alleged the conduct, if proven, would violate Oklahoma Rules of Professional Conduct Rules 1.15 and 8.4(a), (c), (d) and Rule 1.3 of the Rules Governing Disciplinary Proceedings.
- Foard agreed to reimburse the Client Security Fund for any claims paid on her behalf (principal plus statutory interest) before applying for reinstatement, to pay $238.39 in costs within 180 days, and to comply with Rule 9.1.
- The Court approved and accepted her resignation effective August 26, 2017, struck her name from the Roll of Attorneys, and barred any application for reinstatement for five years.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether resignation pending discipline complies with Rule 8.1 | Bar: Foard's resignation meets Rule 8.1 criteria and may be accepted. | Foard: Voluntarily resigning and waiving contest of allegations. | Court: Approved resignation as compliant with Rule 8.1. |
| Whether alleged misappropriation may be deemed admitted by resignation | Bar: Foard waived right to contest allegations, relieving Bar of proving them. | Foard: Waived contest; acknowledges allegations if proven violate rules. | Court: Accepted waiver; treated allegation as unchallenged for resignation purposes. |
| Reimbursement of Client Security Fund claims | Bar: Foard must reimburse principal and statutory interest before reinstatement if Fund pays claims. | Foard: Agreed to reimburse prior to reinstatement. | Court: Conditioned future reinstatement on reimbursement as agreed. |
| Reinstatement eligibility and conditions | Bar: Five-year bar to applying and compliance with Rule 11 conditions is required. | Foard: Acknowledged five-year waiting period and Rule 11 procedures. | Court: Ordered five-year minimum before application and compliance with Rule 11 and Rule 9.1. |
Key Cases Cited
- None (no reported cases cited in the opinion).
