midpage
346 P.3d 16
Wyo.
2015

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Scott A. Galbreath (defendant) was charged with second-degree sexual abuse of a minor based on alleged sexual intrusion of a 15-year-old by a 29-year-old between Feb 1 and Apr 15, 2013.
  • Galbreath was tried by a jury, convicted, and sentenced to 10–18 years (with credit for time served); he appealed claiming ineffective assistance of trial counsel.
  • Alleged attorney errors: failure to present a witness to admit a December 2013 DNA lab report; inadequate investigation and impeachment of Galbreath’s father (Gary) regarding inconsistent statements and surgery/medication timing; deficient voir dire (failure to probe juror biases re: sexual-abuse cases and to remove a retired defense attorney from the panel).
  • The DNA report compared a mattress cutout to oral swabs from Galbreath and found the partial profile was not consistent with him; no sample from the victim was tested.
  • Gary testified inconsistently with prior statements to police (initially saying he heard the sexual activity, then recanting); defense questioning about medications was undermined when prosecution showed surgery occurred after the police interview.
  • The prosecutor conducted extensive voir dire on sexual-abuse biases; the retired defense attorney was not seated on the jury.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Ineffective assistance for failing to introduce DNA report Galbreath: Report showed no link between him and the mattress, would help defense State: Report didn’t include victim sample; foundational witness not designated; admission risked impeachment issues Court: No prejudice — report did not prove absence of sexual contact with victim and would not have changed outcome
Ineffective assistance for inadequate examination/investigation of Gary (father) Galbreath: Counsel failed to check surgery dates and medications, which led to damaging impeachment State: Gary’s credibility was already damaged by inconsistent police statements and parental bias Court: No prejudice — inconsistencies and relationship to defendant already undermined credibility
Ineffective assistance for voir dire failures Galbreath: Counsel did not sufficiently probe juror biases about child-sex-abuse and failed to remove a prominent juror State: Prosecutor thoroughly questioned jurors about such biases; the prominent juror was not seated Court: No prejudice — issues were explored and no showing of how outcome would differ
Overall ineffective-assistance claim under Strickland Galbreath: Trial errors cumulatively show deficient performance and prejudiced outcome State: Any errors did not create a reasonable probability of a different result Court: Claim fails for lack of demonstrated prejudice; conviction affirmed

Key Cases Cited

  • Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (established two-prong ineffective assistance test)
  • Frias v. State, 722 P.2d 135 (Wyo. 1986) (adoption of Strickland standard in Wyoming)
  • Bloomer v. State, 233 P.3d 971 (Wyo. 2010) (definition of deficient performance; prejudice standard)
  • Eaton v. State, 192 P.3d 36 (Wyo. 2008) (failure to prove either Strickland prong is fatal)
  • Sanchez v. State, 253 P.3d 136 (Wyo. 2011) (bald assertions of prejudice insufficient)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Scott A. Galbreath
Court Name: Wyoming Supreme Court
Date Published: Mar 27, 2015
Citations: 346 P.3d 16; 2015 WY 49; 2015 Wyo. LEXIS 53; 2015 WL 1393420; S-14-0169
Docket Number: S-14-0169
Court Abbreviation: Wyo.
Log In