midpage
989 F.3d 359
5th Cir.
2021
Read the full case

Background:

  • A sinkhole formed at Bayou Corne, Louisiana on August 3, 2012 near decades of Texas Brine’s salt-mining activity; landowners sued for pre-sinkhole subsidence and post-sinkhole stigma and restoration claims.
  • The Sanchez class (owners within two miles) asserted both pre-sinkhole subsidence claims and post-sinkhole stigma and a unique fill-in-the-sinkhole claim (Landry).
  • Pre-2012 insurers (including Zurich and AIG) issued policies that expired before August 3, 2012; plaintiffs settled with the pre-2012 insurers to dismiss pre-sinkhole claims in exchange for $1,000,000 and a release of pre-sinkhole claims.
  • Texas Brine (not a settling party) objected, arguing the 2011 Zurich policy (Mar. 1, 2011–Mar. 1, 2012) covered post-sinkhole claims (stigma and Landry’s fill-in claim), so the settlement prejudiced its right to indemnity/contribution.
  • The district court approved the settlement; on appeal the Fifth Circuit held Texas Brine lacked standing because it failed to prove the 2011 Zurich policy covered the post-sinkhole claims (experts could not show the triggering physical injury occurred during the policy period; stigma damage arose only at the sinkhole’s emergence).

Issues:

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether a non-settling defendant (Texas Brine) has standing to object to a class settlement Settlement does not legally prejudice Texas Brine because it releases only pre-sinkhole claims; Texas Brine lacks a cognizable right stripped by settlement Texas Brine contends the settlement strips its contribution/indemnity rights by eliminating insurers that covered the causal period Texas Brine lacks standing absent plain legal prejudice; must show a right to contribution/indemnity that the settlement injures
Whether the 2011 Zurich policy covers Landry’s fill-in-the-sinkhole claim (physical injury) Plaintiffs: the fill-in claim arises from physical injury that manifested with the sinkhole in Aug 2012, outside the policy period Texas Brine: exposure theory — damaging exposure began during the 2011 policy period, so coverage attaches even if manifestation came later Held: Texas Brine failed to prove the physical injury (or an occurrence/exposure) occurred within the 2011 policy period; burden not met
Whether the 2011 Zurich policy covers stigma (loss-of-use) claims from the sinkhole Plaintiffs: stigma resulted from the sinkhole’s catastrophic emergence on Aug 3, 2012, so loss occurred at manifestation (after policy expired) Texas Brine: pre-sinkhole deformation shows exposure during the policy period that could create coverage Held: Stigma damages are tied to the sinkhole’s emergence (Aug 3, 2012); therefore no coverage under the 2011 policy and no plain legal prejudice

Key Cases Cited

  • Lujan v. Defenders of Wildlife, 504 U.S. 555 (standing requires concrete, particularized injury)
  • Transamerican Refin. Corp. v. Dravo Corp., 952 F.2d 898 (5th Cir. 1992) (non-settling parties generally lack standing to challenge class settlements)
  • Bass v. Phoenix Seadrill/78, Ltd., 749 F.2d 1154 (5th Cir. 1985) (adopting Seventh Circuit’s plain-legal-prejudice standard for non-party objections)
  • Cole v. Celotex Corp., 599 So. 2d 1058 (La. 1992) (exposure theory and pro rata allocation for latent injuries)
  • Norfolk S. Corp. v. Cal. Union Ins. Co., 859 So. 2d 167 (La. Ct. App. 2003) (summarizing manifestation vs. exposure approaches)
  • Reynolds v. Select Props., Ltd., 634 So. 2d 1180 (La. 1994) (policy interpretation governed by parties’ intent expressed in the policy)
  • Gandy v. United Servs. Auto. Ass’n, 721 So. 2d 34 (La. Ct. App. 1998) (insured bears burden to prove policy coverage)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Sanchez v. TX Brine
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit
Date Published: Mar 1, 2021
Citations: 989 F.3d 359; 20-30208
Docket Number: 20-30208
Court Abbreviation: 5th Cir.
Log In