Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.2016Background
- Pro se plaintiff Alonzo Ross, an inmate, sued five DOCCS medical staff alleging Eighth Amendment deliberate indifference (chronic pain, heart condition, asthma, neurontin discontinuation) and First Amendment retaliation.
- Defendants moved for summary judgment; Ross cross-moved. Magistrate Judge Stewart recommended granting most of defendants’ motion but allowing an Eighth Amendment claim to survive against Nurse Practitioner Amy Ferguson and Dr. V. Mannava for discontinuing Ross’s Neurontin prescription.
- Defendants objected, arguing medical-record notations ("crush," "drank water," "chalky mush") and a supplemental declaration show Neurontin wasn’t cheeked/ diverted, so the claim should be dismissed; they submitted the supplemental evidence only at the objection stage.
- Ross objected to dismissals on exhaustion, adequacy of care, chronology of medical knowledge, and retaliation theories, largely rehashing earlier arguments.
- The district court reviewed de novo where required, declined to consider defendants’ new evidence (no adequate justification for not presenting it earlier), adopted the magistrate judge’s Report-Recommendation in full, dismissed most claims, and allowed only the Eighth Amendment claim against Ferguson and Mannava (Neurontin discontinuation) to survive. Defendants were given 30 days to file a new summary judgment motion without prejudice.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Eighth Amendment claim based on discontinuing Neurontin survives | Ross: discontinuation caused withdrawal/pain; deliberate indifference | Defs: records show medication was administered as crushed/diluted, undermining diversion allegation | Survives against Ferguson and Mannava; other medical claims dismissed |
| Personal involvement of Koenigsmann in Eighth Amendment claims | Ross: supervisory liability asserted | Defs: Koenigsmann lacked personal involvement | Dismissed for lack of personal involvement |
| First Amendment retaliation claims | Ross: alleged threats, false accusations, and failure to address grievances constituted retaliation | Defs: qualified immunity for Reese and Ferguson; no adverse action/causal link for Mannava and Ramineni | Dismissed: qualified immunity and lack of evidence as to causation/adverse action |
| Consideration of supplemental evidence submitted with objections | Ross: opposed new evidence; sought adoption of magistrate’s findings | Defs: new declaration proves Neurontin was not diluted and defeats claim | Court declined to consider new evidence (no adequate excuse for late submission); denied defendants’ objection and left issue for renewed motion |
Key Cases Cited
- Mario v. P&C Food Markets, Inc., 313 F.3d 758 (2d Cir. 2002) (objections must be specific to preserve review)
- Paddington Partners v. Bouchard, 34 F.3d 1132 (2d Cir. 1994) (district court may refuse new evidence at objections absent justification)
- Pan Am. World Airways, Inc. v. Int'l Bhd. of Teamsters, 894 F.2d 36 (2d Cir. 1990) (failure to justify presenting new testimony at objection stage permits district court to decline it)
- United States v. Raddatz, 447 U.S. 667 (1980) (de novo review does not require a second evidentiary hearing)