Slip Opinion
D. Conn.2018Background
- Plaintiff Ali Richard, a Moorish-American inmate at MacDougall-Walker, alleges denial of religious items (a fez and a religious book), mail tampering (removal of return addresses), and retaliation by prison officials; he sues 13 DOC employees under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and RLUIPA, seeking injunctive and monetary relief.
- Richard requested permission to purchase a fez (claimed essential to Moorish practice); a Religious Review Committee denied the request citing security; his appeal was denied.
- He ordered a book titled Nationality, Birthrights, and Jurisprudence; media review had earlier rejected it, but DOC later reversed; mailroom staff returned the book to the vendor, allegedly in retaliation.
- Two incoming letters from the Moorish religious leader had return addresses torn off; Richard filed grievances that were denied.
- The court conducted initial review under 28 U.S.C. § 1915A and allowed some federal claims to proceed (Free Exercise, RLUIPA, Establishment, Equal Protection, retaliation) against specified defendants, dismissed other claims (certain mail interference and state constitutional claims), and declined supplemental jurisdiction over several state-constitutional claims.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Free Exercise — fez and book denial | Denial substantially burdens his sincerely held Moorish practices by blocking essential religious items | Denial justified by legitimate penological/security interests | Court allowed Free Exercise claims re: fez and book to proceed against committee and mailroom defendants (but dismissed Free Exercise claim re: return-address removal) |
| RLUIPA — substantial burden and least restrictive means | DOC actions substantially burden religious exercise and must meet strict scrutiny | DOC asserts compelling/security interests and alternatives | RLUIPA claims allowed to proceed against same defendants in their official capacities for equitable relief (no individual-capacity RLUIPA damages) |
| Establishment Clause — disparate treatment (crowns vs. fez) | Committee favored Nation of Islam/Five Percenters by permitting crowns but denying fez | DOC cites secular security reasons for denial | Establishment claim allowed against Committee Defendants; Establishment claims against mailroom defendants (book return, return-address) dismissed |
| Equal Protection — religious discrimination | Treated differently than similarly situated inmates (crowns allowed, fez denied) | Defendants cite neutral security policy | Equal Protection claim allowed vs. Committee Defendants regarding fez; equal protection claims vs. mailroom defendants dismissed for failure to allege similarly situated comparators |
| Mail interference (return-address removal) | Removal of return addresses violated mail rights and obstructed religious correspondence | Two isolated incidents, no prejudice, and not a pattern; justified by penological concerns | Claims based on removal of return addresses dismissed as insufficient (no pattern, no prejudice) |
| Due Process — book returned before appeal decided | Returning the book deprived property without process | State provides adequate post-deprivation remedies (administrative process and Claims Commission) | Due process (Fifth) claim dismissed for failure to state claim (adequate post-deprivation remedies) |
| Retaliation — returning book after grievances | Book returned in retaliation for grievances about mail practices | Defendants deny retaliatory motive; routine mail handling/administrative actions | Retaliation claim allowed to proceed against mailroom defendants based on sufficiently pleaded causal link and adverse action |
| Connecticut Constitution claims | Violations of Art. I §§ 3, 8, 14, 20 | State defendants assert federal forum and limited state private causes of action | Court declined supplemental jurisdiction over §§ 3, 8, 20 claims (dismissed); allowed claim under Art. I § 14 (redress of grievances) against mailroom defendants to proceed |
Key Cases Cited
- Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (pleading standard — plausibility)
- Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (pleading standard — plausibility)
- O'Lone v. Estate of Shabazz, 482 U.S. 342 (prisoners retain First Amendment protections balanced against penological interests)
- Salahuddin v. Goord, 467 F.3d 263 (Second Circuit Free Exercise reasonableness/substantial burden framework in prisons)
- Holt v. Hobbs, 135 S. Ct. 853 (RLUIPA and strict scrutiny for substantial burdens on religious exercise)
- Hudson v. Palmer, 468 U.S. 517 (post-deprivation remedies and property loss)
- Holland v. Goord, 758 F.3d 215 (limits on RLUIPA remedies; official-capacity relief only)