Slip Opinion
Sup. Ct. R.I.2011Background
- RIRRC sues VLC, VLTC, and Van Liew for breach of contract, fiduciary breach, aiding breach, negligence, and indemnity related to investment management of Remediation and Closure Trust Funds and Pension Plan.
- RFQs/RFPs and accompanying proposals in the mid-1990s selected VLTC and Van Liew to manage and trustee funds; St. Sauveur, a RIRRC commissioner, also served on VLTC/VLC boards, creating potential conflicts of interest not disclosed.
- Remediation Trust Fund (1996 Agreement) and Closure Trust Fund (1998 Trust Agreement) required VLTC to invest and manage under RIRRC's policies; included indemnification and fiduciary duties.
- Pension Plan (2002/2004) involvement tied VLTC and Van Liew to governance and investment management, with indemnity provisions and disclosure expectations.
- Complaint alleges fiduciary duty arising from investment management/control over funds; Defendants move to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6) arguing lack of contract and improper parties.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Existence of contract and personal liability | RIRRC alleges contracts included Van Liew/VLTC; VLTC's proposal shows mixed participation; veil piercing urged. | Van Liew not a party; no contractual relationship to impose liability; veil piercing not properly pleaded. | Van Liew dismissed; VLC remains potentially liable; contract-based liability not shown against Van Liew. |
| Breach of fiduciary duty (Count II) | VLC/Van Liew owed fiduciary duties arising from investment management/control and reliance by RIRRC. | No fiduciary duty plaintiff can prove arising from defendants to RIRRC. | Counts II viable; duty and breach alleged; claims survive dismissal. |
| Aiding and abetting breach of fiduciary duty (Count III) | VLC and Van Liew knowingly participated in or aided breach by St. Sauveur through non-disclosure. | Plaintiff failed to show substantial assistance or duty to disclose. | Counts III viable; claims sufficiently pled for aiding and abetting. |
| Negligence (Count IV) | Professionals owed duty of care in administering/investing funds; breach through unsuitable investments and undisclosed conflicts. | No contractual relationship; no duty owed. | Count IV viable; duty and breach alleged; negligence claim survives. |
Key Cases Cited
- Petrarca v. Fidelity Cas. Ins. Co., 884 A.2d 406 (R.I. 2005) (breach of contract elements and damages requirement)
- Bullmore v. Ernst Young Cayman Islands, 45 A.D.3d 461 (N.Y. App. Div. 2007) (fiduciary duty concept independent of contract)
- Filippi v. Filippi, 818 A.2d 608 (R.I. 2003) (objective mutual assent in contract formation)
- Roy v. General Elec. Co., 544 F. Supp. 2d 103 (D.R.I. 2008) (documents integral to complaint may be considered on 12(b)(6))
- Jorge v. Rumsfeld, 404 F.3d 556 (1st Cir. 2005) (when a document is expressly relied upon in a complaint, it merges into pleadings)
- Beddall v. State St. Bank & Trust Co., 137 F.3d 12 (1st Cir. 1998) (documents integral to complaint may be considered; standard for incorporation by reference)
- Bruno v. Criterion Holdings, Inc., 736 A.2d 99 (R.I. 1999) (piercing corporate veil not allowed where pleading deficient)
- U.S. v. Kayser-Roth Corp., Inc., 103 F. Supp. 2d 74 (D.R.I. 2000) (corporate form may be disregarded under unity of ownership)
- National Hotel Ass'n v. O. Ahlborg Sons, Inc., 827 A.2d 646 (R.I. 2003) (veil piercing factors and unity of interest)