Slip Opinion
N.D. Cal.2022Background
- Plaintiff Jarrett Reeves bought PokeCoins in the Niantic Pokemon app while a minor and, shortly after turning 18, sued Niantic seeking refunds and other relief based on his right to disaffirm contracts made as a minor.
- Reeves alleges Niantic did not refund purchases and retained money he is entitled to recover; he disaffirmed several in-app purchases and seeks restitution, declaratory relief, UCL and CLRA relief, and tort claims.
- Niantic moved to dismiss; the court granted the motion in part and denied it in part and denied the parties' request for judicial notice as moot.
- Court allowed UCL claims based on unlawful and unfair practices to proceed but dismissed the UCL claim grounded in fraud for failure to allege reliance.
- Court affirmed a declaratory-judgment claim that an actual controversy exists about minors' rights to disaffirm and obtain refunds under Cal. Fam. Code § 6710.
- Court dismissed the CLRA claim with prejudice (amendment futile), and dismissed claims for restitution/unjust enrichment and negligent misrepresentation with leave to amend (except CLRA).
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| UCL — unlawful and unfair practices | Reeves argues Niantic violated minors' right to disaffirm purchases and retained funds unlawfully | Niantic contends no viable UCL claim and disputes liability due to app-store refund mechanics | Allowed: UCL unlawful and unfair claims plausibly pleaded and survive dismissal |
| UCL — fraud-based claim | Reeves alleges Niantic misled him about refundability/omitted disclosure | Niantic argues Reeves cannot have relied because he was unaware of policy and would not have looked for refund info | Dismissed: fraud-based UCL fails for lack of reliance |
| Declaratory judgment re disaffirmance rights | Reeves seeks declaration that minors may disaffirm and obtain refunds under Cal. Fam. Code § 6710 | Niantic argues claim is moot or premature because Reeves is now an adult and refunds are handled by app stores | Allowed: actual controversy exists; claim viable despite plaintiff reaching majority and despite refund mechanics |
| CLRA applicability to virtual currency | Reeves contends PokeCoins transaction falls within CLRA as goods or services | Niantic argues PokeCoins are intangible and not CLRA "goods"; not a CLRA "service" either | Dismissed with prejudice: PokeCoins not "tangible chattels" nor CLRA "services" as defined |
| Restitution / unjust enrichment & negligent misrepresentation | Reeves seeks equitable restitution and alleges misrepresentations | Niantic argues Reeves has adequate legal remedies and failed to plead reliance for misrepresentation | Dismissed: restitution/unjust enrichment fail for lack of showing inadequate legal remedy; negligent misrepresentation fails for same reasons as UCL fraud; leave to amend on some claims |
Key Cases Cited
- I.B. ex rel. Fife v. Facebook, Inc., 905 F. Supp. 2d 989 (N.D. Cal.) (discussing unfair business practices and declaratory relief principles)
- Doe v. Epic Games, Inc., 435 F. Supp. 3d 1024 (N.D. Cal.) (addressing requirements for pre-suit refund attempts and scope of relief against game companies)
- Sonner v. Premier Nutrition Corp., 971 F.3d 834 (9th Cir.) (equitable restitution requires showing lack of adequate legal remedy)