Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.2012Background
- Reed, proceeding pro se, sues under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 against John Doe No. 1, John Doe No. 2, and M. Soto in the Northern District of New York.
- Magistrate Judge Peebles issued a Report-Recommendation recommending dismissal of Soto with leave to amend within 30 days.
- Peebles denied Reed’s motions for leave to amend and for appointment of counsel, without prejudice to renewal.
- Soto objected to the leave-to-amend recommendation; Reed objected, arguing retaliation claims or entitlement to counsel.
- The district court reviewed de novo objections and adopted the report, dismissing Soto with prejudice unless Reed files a proper amended complaint.
- Amended complaints must conform to the guidance in the Report-Recommendation, replacing prior pleadings, and include specific factual allegations against each defendant.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Soto should be dismissed and whether leave to amend should be granted | Reed seeks amendment to plead plausible retaliation claims against Soto | Soto argues failure to state a claim and argues against leave to amend | Soto dismissed with leave to amend |
| Whether Reed should receive permission to amend the complaint | Amendment necessary to plead plausible retaliation | Amendment futile due to lack of plausible claims | Leave to replead granted with requirements |
| Whether Reed's motions for appointment of counsel were properly denied | Request denied; court should appoint counsel | No entitlement to appointed counsel at this stage | Objections to denial are appellate and rejected; denial affirmed |
| Whether the court should adopt the magistrate's recommendations | Disagreement with recommendations; seek different outcome | Recommendations are correct and should be adopted | Court adopted the magistrate's recommendations in full |
Key Cases Cited
- Cortec Industries, Inc. v. Sum Holding L.P., 949 F.2d 42 (2d Cir. 1991) (usual practice to grant leave to replead after dismissal)
- Bass v. Jackson, 790 F.2d 260 (2d Cir. 1986) (involvement required for constitutional deprivations; pleading standards)
- Barr v. Abrams, 810 F.2d 358 (2d Cir. 1987) (cited for general pleading standards and to avoid speculative pleadings)
- Perez v. Ortiz, 849 F.2d 793 (2d Cir. 1988) (requirement that amended pleadings be a complete replacement for prior filings)