midpage
921 F.3d 599
6th Cir.
2019

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Redlin was a high-school assistant principal at Grosse Pointe South (hired 2012). In 2014–15 she complained informally to Deputy Superintendent Jon Dean about comments/conduct by principal Moussa Hamka she perceived as gender-based harassment. Dean investigated informally and found no harassment; Redlin did not pursue a formal complaint.
  • Two incidents precipitated discipline: (1) Redlin warned a teacher (C.M.) about another assistant principal's (Flint’s) evaluation; (2) Redlin and others knew, but did not report, a rumor concerning Hamka and a teacher (L.L.). Dean told Redlin she would be disciplined but held discipline in abeyance while she sought another job.
  • Redlin received a "minimally effective" evaluation for 2014–2015, was placed on an Individualized Development Plan (IDP), denied a rolling two-year contract and merit pay, and was later transferred to a middle school. Flint engaged in similar misconduct (warning a coworker, lying to Dean, and knowledge of the L.L. rumor) but received lighter discipline and an "effective" evaluation.
  • Redlin took FMLA leave from Nov 17, 2015 to Mar 14, 2016. Upon return there was some confusion about whether she would receive an interim or full evaluation; she ultimately received an "effective" rating and two-year contract.
  • Procedural posture: Redlin filed EEOC charge and then suit alleging Title VII and Michigan Elliott-Larsen Act (ELCRA) sex discrimination and retaliation, and FMLA retaliation. District court granted summary judgment to the school district; Sixth Circuit AFFIRMED as to FMLA claim but REVERSED and REMANDED the Title VII/ELCRA discrimination and retaliation claims for trial.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Sex discrimination (Title VII & ELCRA): whether Redlin was discriminatorily treated (transfer, "minimally effective" rating, IDP, pay effects) Redlin: her transfer, downgraded evaluation, and harsher discipline vs. Flint show gender-based disparate treatment; creates jury question on pretext District: actions were nondiscriminatory discipline for misconduct; Flint not similarly situated or disciplined by different supervisors Reversed as to discrimination; jury issue exists because comparator evidence and employer explanations raise genuine factual disputes about pretext
Retaliation for opposing sex discrimination (Title VII & ELCRA): whether adverse actions were caused by her complaint to Dean Redlin: she complained to Dean (protected activity); temporal proximity, Niehaus admitted the transfer was due in part to her "gender complaint," and differential treatment vs. Flint show causation District: adverse actions were justified by nondiscriminatory reasons; timing and causal link insufficient Reversed as to retaliation; sufficient circumstantial evidence (temporal evidence, Niehaus testimony, comparator treatment) to create genuine issue on causation and pretext
FMLA retaliation: whether taking FMLA leave led to adverse actions upon return Redlin: after leave she was told she would get only an interim evaluation, remain on IDP, and lose rolling contract — adverse acts that could deter employees from taking leave District: any confusion was temporary; Redlin in fact received a full evaluation, effective rating, two-year contract, and no ongoing adverse action Affirmed as to FMLA claim; no genuine dispute that an adverse employment action occurred after FMLA leave
Comparator/similar-employee analysis: whether Flint is a proper comparator for showing pretext and causation Redlin: Flint and Redlin engaged in similar misconduct under the same standards and Dean was involved in both discipline decisions, making them similarly situated District: Flint had different supervisors/discipline; therefore not similarly situated Court: Flint is a valid comparator here given common involvement of Dean and shared standards; comparator evidence supports jury inference of pretext

Key Cases Cited

  • McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green, 411 U.S. 792 (establishes burden-shifting framework for indirect evidence discrimination)
  • Univ. of Tex. Southwestern Med. Ctr. v. Nassar, 570 U.S. 338 (but-for causation standard for Title VII retaliation)
  • Burlington N. & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. White, 548 U.S. 53 (standard for materially adverse action in retaliation context)
  • Baxter Healthcare Corp. v. 533 F.3d 381 (6th Cir.) (tangible employment action requirement for negative evaluations)
  • Chen v. Dow Chem. Co., 580 F.3d 394 (6th Cir.) (methods to show pretext)
  • Ercegovich v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co., 154 F.3d 344 (6th Cir.) (guidance on what makes employees similarly situated)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Redlin v. Grosse Pointe Pub. Sch. Sys.
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
Date Published: Apr 16, 2019
Citations: 921 F.3d 599; No. 18-1641
Docket Number: No. 18-1641
Court Abbreviation: 6th Cir.
Log In