midpage
693 F.3d 87
1st Cir.
2012

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Rebenko, a Ukrainian Pentecostal, entered the U.S. in 2001 on a J-1 visa and later held an F-1 visa through 2006.
  • She filed an affirmative asylum and withholding of removal application on October 12, 2004; DHS issued a notice of intent to deny in 2007 and removal proceedings followed in September 2007.
  • An IJ denied asylum, withholding of removal, and CAT relief but granted voluntary departure; the BIA affirmed on September 8, 2011.
  • Rebenko testified to four incidents of mistreatment tied to her faith (1999 arrest, threatening calls, 2000 graduation harassment, and a 2000 beating by skinheads).
  • Expert testimony from Kotler suggested grave risk on return, but the IJ and BIA relied on country reports showing religious freedom and growth of Protestant churches in Ukraine.
  • The court reviews the IJ/BIA decision on a unitary record and grants relief only if findings are supported by substantial evidence.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether past persecution by Ukraine is shown Rebenko; past incidents amount to persecution. BIA found incidents not sufficiently severe or systemic to constitute persecution. Substantial evidence supports no past persecution
Whether well-founded fear requires past persecution proof Fear can be established directly without past persecution. Objective basis must be shown; past-persecution presumption not satisfied here. IJ/BIA properly analyzed fear without relying on past persecution; no objective basis shown
Whether the CAT analysis must be independently considered IJ/BIA failed to independently analyze CAT claim. CAT issue was not challenged on appeal and is forfeited; merits lack. CAT claim not independently analyzed; issue forfeited and meritless

Key Cases Cited

  • Hussain v. Holder, 576 F.3d 54 (1st Cir. 2009) (review of BIA/IJ as a unit; substantial evidence standard)
  • Seng v. Holder, 584 F.3d 13 (1st Cir. 2009) (record review standard; acceptance of factual findings)
  • Nikijuluw v. Gonzales, 427 F.3d 115 (1st Cir. 2005) (evidence-based review; defer to agency findings)
  • Mendez-Barrera v. Holder, 602 F.3d 21 (1st Cir. 2010) (de novo review of law; substantial evidence for facts)
  • Butt v. Keisler, 506 F.3d 86 (1st Cir. 2007) (persecution nexus; government action/inaction required)
  • Morgan v. Holder, 634 F.3d 53 (1st Cir. 2011) (credibility does not prove causal nexus)
  • Alibeaj v. Gonzales, 469 F.3d 188 (1st Cir. 2006) (high threshold for persecution; frequency and seriousness)
  • Journal v. Keisler, 507 F.3d 9 (1st Cir. 2007) (persecution analysis; government response critical)
  • Susanto v. Gonzales, 439 F.3d 57 (1st Cir. 2006) (persecution standards; private conduct with state failure)
  • Topalli v. Gonzales, 417 F.3d 128 (1st Cir. 2005) (past persecution; nexus and frequency considerations)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Rebenko v. Holder
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
Date Published: Sep 4, 2012
Citations: 693 F.3d 87; 2012 U.S. App. LEXIS 18593; 2012 WL 3793128; 11-2171
Docket Number: 11-2171
Court Abbreviation: 1st Cir.
Log In