midpage
275 P.3d 478
Wyo.
2012

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Poitra Jr. and two others robbed a Sheridan home; Ernst was killed during the burglary.
  • The group planned burglaries beforehand and used stolen weapons; Poitra opened a window and doors for co‑defendants.
  • Poitra was convicted of felony murder, aggravated burglary, and conspiracy; he was sentenced to life without parole.
  • Poitra sought to introduce involuntary intoxication as a defense related to akathisia from Seroquel; he had NGMI status but withdrew it.
  • The court denied involuntary intoxication evidence, denied an involuntary intoxication jury instruction, denied a change of venue, and Poitra challenges sentence as arbitrary.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Involuntary intoxication as a defense without NGMI plea Poitra argues involuntary intoxication is a valid defense even without NGMI entry. State contends involuntary intoxication is not recognized without proper statutory/case groundwork. Involuntary intoxication defense available under §7‑11‑304(a); Poitra barred by NGMI withdrawal; no error in exclusion.
Failure to instruct on involuntary intoxication Poitra contends the court should have instructed on involuntary intoxication. State argues proposed instruction is invalid absent a recognized defense. No instructional error; defense not recognized without proper plea.
Denial of change of venue due to pretrial/prejudice Poitra claims community prejudice and pretrial publicity denied a fair trial. State argues publicity was not prejudicial enough to compel transfer. Court did not abuse discretion; venue denial affirmed.
Sentence arbitrary and capricious Poitra argues his sentence is excessive given his lesser role and non-shooting involvement. State asserts individualized sentencing and aggravating/mitigating factors support the term. No abuse of discretion; sentence affirmed.

Key Cases Cited

  • Gustavenson v. State, 10 Wyo. 300, 68 P. 1006 (1902) (Wy. 1902) (involuntary intoxication historically recognized as defense vs. insanity)
  • Rice v. State, 500 P.2d 675 (Wyo. 1972) (Wy. 1972) (insanity defense for involuntary intoxication; voluntary intoxication limits)
  • Juarez, 256 P.3d 517 (Wyo. 2011) (Wy. 2011) (statutory interpretation of §7‑11‑304(a) de novo review)
  • Bouwkamp v. State, 833 P.2d 486 (Wyo. 1992) (Wy. 1992) (instruction must present a defense recognized by statute or case law)
  • Proffit v. State, 191 P.3d 963 (Wyo. 2008) (Wy. 2008) (change of venue standard based on prejudice; totality of circumstances)
  • Wilcox v. State, 670 P.2d 1116 (Wyo. 1983) (Wy. 1983) (prejudice not required to be ignorant of facts; focus on fair jury)
  • Shaffer v. State, 640 P.2d 88 (Wyo. 1982) (Wy. 1982) (presiding considerations in voir dire and voir dire fairness)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Poitra v. State
Court Name: Wyoming Supreme Court
Date Published: Apr 12, 2012
Citations: 275 P.3d 478; 2012 WY 58; 2012 WL 1216476; 2012 Wyo. LEXIS 61; S-11-0085
Docket Number: S-11-0085
Court Abbreviation: Wyo.
Log In