50 Cal.App.5th 17
Cal. Ct. App.2020Background
- At ~2:00 a.m. officers responded to a report of a suspicious person in a parked pickup; appellant was seated in the driver’s seat and gave his name and address but had no ID on him.
- Dispatch (erroneously) reported appellant was on probation and a Penal Code § 290 registrant; appellant denied probation.
- Based on dispatch, Officer Salvio conducted a probation search of appellant and found methamphetamine on his person; Officer Coronel later reached into the slightly open passenger window and uncovered a meth pipe under a blanket on the seat.
- Parties stipulated at the suppression hearing that appellant was not on probation; the dispatcher’s information was erroneous.
- The trial court denied the suppression motion, finding the officers reasonably treated the stop as a probation search and alternatively that Coronel’s observation of a bulge furnished probable cause to search under the blanket.
- The Court of Appeal reversed: probation-search exception inapplicable without knowledge of search condition; the People failed to carry burden on the good-faith exception; alternative vehicle-search theories were forfeited and unsupported by the record.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether warrantless searches of appellant and truck were lawful under the probation-search exception | Dispatch advised appellant was on probation/§290 registrant; officers reasonably assumed probation included search terms | Appellant was not on probation; police had no advance knowledge he was subject to search conditions; probation exception requires such knowledge | Reversed: probation exception inapplicable because officers lacked knowledge of a search condition at the time of the searches |
| Whether the good-faith exception saves the searches | Officers reasonably relied on dispatcher/rap sheet; suppression not required | No evidence of objectively reasonable reliance; officer’s subjective belief insufficient | Reversed: People failed to prove good-faith exception; subjective belief of a fairly new officer inadequate to meet objective standard |
| Whether officer Coronel had reasonable suspicion or probable cause to search under the blanket for weapons | Bulge under blanket and appellant’s behavior justified a protective search or probable cause | Bodycam and testimony do not support reasonable suspicion; sequence of searches shows person was searched before truck; People didn’t press this theory below | Reversed: alternative weapon-search theory forfeited and, on the record/video, unsupported |
| Whether alternative justifications raised for first time on appeal can uphold the searches | Now argues independent bases (suspicious bulge, conduct) justify searches | These theories were not argued or developed below and are factually unsupported | Forfeited: appellate court will not accept new, undeveloped justifications lacking record support |
Key Cases Cited
- United States v. Leon, 468 U.S. 897 (1984) (good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule)
- Herring v. United States, 555 U.S. 135 (2009) (good-faith inquiry is objective: would a reasonably well-trained officer know the search was illegal)
- Michigan v. Long, 463 U.S. 1032 (1983) (vehicle passenger-compartment protective search standard)
- People v. Willis, 28 Cal.4th 22 (2002) (burden on People to prove warrantless search reasonable; good-faith exception addressed)
- People v. Romeo, 240 Cal.App.4th 931 (2015) (probation search inapplicable when officers lack knowledge of a search condition)
- People v. Hoeninghaus, 120 Cal.App.4th 1180 (2004) (probation-search exception requires officer awareness of search condition)
- People v. Thomas, 29 Cal.App.5th 1107 (2018) (same principle: probation searches need officer knowledge of search terms)
- People v. Bravo, 43 Cal.3d 600 (1987) (probationer’s consent via probation condition can allow suspicionless searches)