2023 IL App (2d) 210548-U
Ill. App. Ct.2023Background
- In 2010 (trial in absentia) Augustine Montes was convicted of attempted first‑degree murder and aggravated discharge of a firearm; a jury found he personally discharged a firearm. He received 26 years (including a 20‑year firearm enhancement) and a concurrent 10‑year term for aggravated discharge.
- Trial evidence included testimony and a covert recording from government informant Blake Pannell: Montes left a car with a gun, pursued Julian Ramos, later returned, grabbed the gun, exited again, was heard saying he tried to “bump” Ramos and hearing “click, click, click,” and a gunshot is on the recording. Montes was recorded asking to shower after the incident.
- Montes’s initial postconviction petition (2014) alleged actual innocence via entrapment and was summarily dismissed and affirmed on appeal; Hernandez’s affidavit then said he did not know whether Montes fired the shot.
- In a successive postconviction petition Montes produced a 2018 affidavit from Jean‑Marc Faison, who asserted he fired a single warning shot that night and that Montes did not fire. Montes said he first learned Faison’s story in 2015 while incarcerated with him.
- The trial court granted the State’s second‑stage motion to dismiss the successive petition. On appeal the court affirmed dismissal as to the attempted murder conviction but reversed as to the aggravated‑discharge conviction and the personal‑discharge sentencing enhancement, remanding for a third‑stage evidentiary hearing on those claims.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the Faison affidavit is "newly discovered"/diligent presentation | State: Montes learned facts earlier and delayed filing; lack of due diligence | Montes: could not know Faison’s identity/info until meeting him in 2015; delays explained by incarceration and Faison’s later willingness | Court: affidavit is newly discovered and Montes showed sufficient diligence |
| Whether Montes’s prior postconviction entrapment claim estops current actual‑innocence claim | State: prior petition effectively admitted Montes fired and bars inconsistent claim | Montes: prior petition didn’t admit he fired; Hernandez’s affidavit uncertain; entrapment was not properly raised | Court: prior petition does not bar successive actual‑innocence claim |
| Whether Faison’s affidavit is material and noncumulative | State: it merely impeaches trial witnesses and is not outcome‑determinative | Montes: affidavit provides affirmative, new identification of an alternate shooter | Court: affidavit is material to ultimate issues and noncumulative |
| Whether the affidavit is of such conclusive character that it would probably change the result on retrial | State: case against Montes was strong; even if someone else fired a shot, evidence still supports attempted murder; affidavit won’t likely change results | Montes: only one gunshot was heard; if Faison fired it Montes is exonerated on some counts | Court: Affirmed dismissal as to attempted murder (evidence of intent and substantial step remains strong); reversed and remanded for an evidentiary hearing as to aggravated discharge and the personal‑discharge enhancement (affidavit could probably change those findings) |
Key Cases Cited
- People v. Robinson, 2020 IL 123849 (explains standards for newly discovered evidence, materiality, noncumulativeness, and conclusive character in actual‑innocence claims)
- People v. Pitsonbarger, 205 Ill. 2d 444 (postconviction Act provides remedy for constitutional violations at trial/sentencing)
- People v. Ortiz, 235 Ill. 2d 319 (postconviction review limited to claims not adjudicated on direct appeal)
- People v. Sanders, 2016 IL 118123 (standards governing second‑stage dismissal and advancement to evidentiary hearing)
- People v. Ward, 187 Ill. 2d 249 (de novo review of second‑stage dismissal and limits on disregarding allegations rebutted by the record)
- People v. Seats, 68 Ill. App. 3d 889 (firing a gun at a person supports intent to kill even if the gun misfires)
- United States ex rel. Hampton v. Leibach, 347 F.3d 219 (a reasonable chance of acquittal need only be better than negligible to warrant further proceedings)