15 Cal. App. Supp. 5th 1
Cal. Super. Ct.2017Background
- At ~4 a.m. on June 13, 2015, CHP Officer Watson stopped Samuel Ling, smelled alcohol, observed signs of intoxication, and administered field sobriety and PAS tests; results supported arrest for DUI.
- Officer arrested, handcuffed, placed Ling in patrol car, and advised him under "implied consent" that because he was under arrest for DUI he "has to submit to a chemical test, either breath or blood." Officer did not explain consequences of refusal.
- Ling did not expressly choose breath or blood at the scene or during transport; the officer drove him to a CHP station where only blood draws were available.
- At the station the officer called for a blood draw; Ling submitted (no vocal or physical resistance) and blood was drawn after the officer completed an 18‑item checklist.
- At the suppression hearing the People relied solely on consent to justify the warrantless blood draw; the trial court denied suppression without detailed findings. The appellate court reversed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the warrantless blood draw was justified by consent | People: Ling submitted to a blood draw and did not refuse or resist, so his submission constituted voluntary consent | Ling: submission was merely acquiescence to officer's asserted authority; no verbal or affirmative manifestation of consent and no informed choice between tests | Held: No valid consent. Totality of circumstances showed submission to authority, not voluntary consent; suppress evidence. |
| Whether exigent‑circumstances doctrine/Schmerber permits warrantless blood draws without a showing of exigency post‑McNeely | People: historically, Schmerber allowed warrantless draws incident to arrest; implied consent statutes reinforced practice | Ling: after McNeely, exigency cannot be presumed; prosecution must show a warrant or an applicable exception (e.g., actual consent) | Held: McNeely requires courts to demand evidence of a warrant or an exception; here People relied only on consent and failed to prove it, so McNeely defeats a presumption of lawfulness. |
Key Cases Cited
- Schmerber v. California, 384 U.S. 757 (warrantless blood draw once reasonable and incident to arrest previously upheld under exigent circumstances)
- Missouri v. McNeely, 569 U.S. 141 (exigency from natural dissipation of alcohol cannot be presumed; warrant or demonstrated exception required)
- Bumper v. North Carolina, 391 U.S. 543 (consent is invalid if given in submission to asserted official authority)
- Schneckloth v. Bustamonte, 412 U.S. 218 (voluntariness of consent judged under totality of circumstances; knowledge of right to refuse is a factor, not a prerequisite)
- People v. Harris, 234 Cal.App.4th 671 (discusses voluntariness and effect of implied‑consent advisals on coercion analysis)