midpage
15 Cal.App.5th 1128
Cal. Ct. App.
2017
Read the full case

Background

  • Nan Hui Jo (defendant) is a Korean citizen who left Sacramento in Nov 2009 with her infant daughter V and lived in South Korea until returning to the U.S. in July 2014; she was arrested on arrival and charged under Penal Code § 278.5 for maliciously depriving a lawful custodian (J.C.) of custody/visitation.
  • The prosecution presented evidence of long-term withholding (Nov 2009–July 2014), J.C.’s family-court filings and many emails urging contact, and communications from a DA Child Abduction Unit investigator.
  • The defense emphasized lack of proof of malice and presented domestic-violence evidence (including an expert) to explain Jo’s state of mind and reasons for departure.
  • The trial court instructed the jury on malice and on CALCRIM No. 1252 (the § 278.7 "good cause" statutory defense) over defense objection and used CALCRIM No. 250 (union of act and intent: general intent) instead of CALCRIM No. 251.
  • The jury excused a juror during deliberations for inability to follow the law, convicted Jo of child custody deprivation, the conviction was reduced to a misdemeanor, and Jo appealed raising instructional, evidentiary, prosecutorial-misconduct, unanimity/election, juror-removal, and sufficiency claims.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument (People) Defendant's Argument (Jo) Held
1. Union of act and intent instruction (CALCRIM No. 250 v. 251) CALCRIM No. 250 was appropriate given prosecution’s theory. Court should have given CALCRIM No. 251 because malice is a specific mental state. Error to give No. 250, but harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
2. Giving CALCRIM No. 1252 (§ 278.7 defense) over objection Instruction necessary because domestic-violence evidence put § 278.7 in play and jury needed legal context. Trial court should not impose an affirmative defense inconsistent with defense theory; Jo did not invoke § 278.7. Court erred in giving CALCRIM No. 1252 over objection, but error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
3. Supplemental jury responses about relation between § 278.5 and § 278.7 Responses correctly explained statutory elements and burden of proof. Court failed to instruct jury that good-faith belief alone (without § 278.7 compliance) is a complete defense. No reversible error; Mehaisin remains good law — compliance with § 278.7(c),(d) required for statutory defense.
4. Admissibility of retired prosecutor’s testimony on § 278.7 Expert could explain the statute’s operation for the jury. Such testimony is an improper legal conclusion for a witness. Admissible; witness gave statutory overview and did not opine on ultimate application.

Key Cases Cited

  • People v. Neidinger, 40 Cal.4th 67 (Cal. 2006) (allocates burden for § 278.7 belief-defense and holds defendant need only raise a reasonable doubt on that belief because it relates to malice)
  • People v. Mehaisin, 101 Cal.App.4th 958 (Cal. Ct. App. 2002) (concludes § 278.7 requires compliance with reporting and custody-proceeding provisions; defense unavailable where reporting/filing not done)
  • People v. Sedeno, 10 Cal.3d 703 (Cal. 1974) (sua sponte instruction duties: court must give instructions on defenses relied upon or if substantial evidence supports a defense not inconsistent with defendant’s theory)
  • People v. Breverman, 19 Cal.4th 142 (Cal. 1998) (reaffirms Sedeno’s framework for sua sponte instructions and clarifies standards)
  • People v. Anderson, 51 Cal.4th 989 (Cal. 2011) (distinguishes evidence negating an element from asserting a separate defense triggering sua sponte duties)
  • Chapman v. California, 386 U.S. 18 (U.S. 1967) (constitutional harmless-error standard; beneficiary of federal constitutional error must show the error did not contribute to the verdict)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: People v. Jo
Court Name: California Court of Appeal
Date Published: Oct 3, 2017
Citations: 15 Cal.App.5th 1128; 224 Cal.Rptr.3d 82; 2017 WL 4385745; 2017 Cal. App. LEXIS 864; C079280
Docket Number: C079280
Court Abbreviation: Cal. Ct. App.
Log In