midpage
2018 IL App (1st) 152067
Ill. App. Ct.
2018

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • On November 26, 2010, Stephen Peters and CPD officer Michael Flisk were shot and killed in an alley after Stephen had reported a burglary of his mother’s garage and was waiting for police; witnesses heard two sets of shots and saw the bodies.
  • Items from the Mustang burglary were later found in garbage cans abandoned a few houses away; a latent fingerprint on a rearview mirror bracket was identified as Herring’s.
  • Several acquaintances and relatives of Timothy Herring told police that Herring admitted shooting two people, described disposing of a gun and clothes, and had braids/cut hair the same day; some initially lied to police and later gave recorded statements.
  • Cell-phone records and cell-site location information placed Herring’s phone in the vicinity of the crime; the prosecution introduced call/text logs and tower-location analysis.
  • The jury convicted Herring of two counts of first-degree murder and burglary; he received a mandatory natural-life sentence (statutorily required because he killed two victims).

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Corpus delicti / Sufficiency of evidence State: corpus delicti (murder) and defendant’s guilt shown by independent evidence (shooting, bodies, fingerprint, phone data, witnesses) Herring: convictions rest solely on his out-of-court admissions; corpus delicti not independently proven Court: corpus delicti proven; evidence (forensic, phone, witness admissions) sufficient for a rational jury to convict
Admissibility of hearsay (Stephen’s statements; 911 call) State: Stephen’s statements admissible as state-of-mind; 911 call admissible as excited utterance Herring: statements and 911 tape were improper hearsay / prejudicial Court: trial court did not abuse discretion — both exceptions apply and probative value outweighed prejudice
Double hearsay / prior inconsistent statements (Menzies→Ebony→police) State: prior inconsistent grand jury statement admissible as substantive; testimony cumulative of Menzies Herring: admission of Ebony’s recounting of Menzies’s report is impermissible double hearsay Court: any double-hearsay error was harmless because Menzies had already testified and Ebony’s evidence was cumulative
Prosecutorial misconduct (closing/opening) State: remarks were proper argument on evidence and inferences; limited improper remarks were corrected by court Herring: prosecutor appealed to emotion, attacked defense as “disgusting”/“nuts,” improperly suggested witnesses feared defendant Court: remarks viewed in context; no reversible misconduct—sustained objections and limited role of comments meant no material prejudice
Ineffective assistance re: fingerprint foundation and cell-location data State: counsel cross-examined fingerprint examiner and strategically declined exclusion; cell-location evidence was weak and cumulative Herring: counsel should have objected to foundation for fingerprint and sought suppression of location data under Carpenter Court: no deficient performance on fingerprint (strategy, weight not admissibility); even if Carpenter suppression merited, no prejudice because location data was non-dispositive
Constitutionality of mandatory natural-life sentence for 19-year-old State: Eighth Amendment protections for juveniles do not extend past 18; sentence lawful Herring: mandatory sentence prevents consideration of youth as mitigating factor Court: federal Eighth Amendment claims fail (defendant was over 18); as-applied Illinois challenge not preserved or developed for review

Key Cases Cited

  • People v. Lara, 2012 IL 112370 (explains corpus delicti requires independent proof of crime)
  • People v. Campbell, 146 Ill. 2d 363 (standard for reviewing sufficiency of evidence)
  • People v. Caffey, 205 Ill. 2d 52 (state-of-mind hearsay exception requirements)
  • People v. Sutton, 233 Ill. 2d 89 (standards for excited utterance/spontaneous declaration)
  • People v. Sangster, 2014 IL App (1st) 113457 (prior inconsistent statement and hearsay discussion)
  • People v. Maldonado, 402 Ill. App. 3d 411 (abuse-of-discretion review for evidentiary rulings)
  • Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (ineffective assistance two-prong test)
  • Carpenter v. United States, 138 S. Ct. 2206 (cell-site location information may constitute a search requiring a warrant)
  • Roper v. Simmons, 543 U.S. 551 (Eighth Amendment protection for juvenile offenders)
  • People v. Harris, 2018 IL 121932 (Illinois guidance on preserved as-applied constitutional claims)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: People v. Herring
Court Name: Appellate Court of Illinois
Date Published: Dec 11, 2018
Citations: 2018 IL App (1st) 152067; 123 N.E.3d 1; 428 Ill.Dec. 537; 1-15-2067
Docket Number: 1-15-2067
Court Abbreviation: Ill. App. Ct.
Log In