midpage
6 Cal. 5th 367
Cal.
2018

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Dora Buenrostro was tried for the 1994 stabbing murders of her three children; a jury convicted her of three counts of first-degree murder, found three multiple-murder special-circumstance allegations true, and returned a death verdict after the penalty phase.
  • Pretrial, a competency inquiry under Penal Code §1368 was held; a jury found Buenrostro competent despite defense experts diagnosing psychotic/delusional disorders and prosecution-appointed experts testifying competency.
  • At the competency trial and later criminal trial, disputed evidence included MMPI results, expert opinions about malingering and proper forensic procedures, and jail writings seized and translated by the prosecution.
  • During guilt-phase jury selection, the trial court excused at least one prospective juror (B.R.) for cause based solely on questionnaire responses about the death penalty.
  • The Supreme Court of California affirmed guilt, vacated two of three multiplicity special-circumstance findings, reversed the death sentence, and remanded for a new penalty determination due to improper excusal of a capital juror.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Constitutionality of §1367 definition of incompetence (requirement of mental disorder) §1367 is constitutional and consistent with Dusky; competency properly requires a causal mental condition §1367 is facially inadequate because it requires proof of a mental disorder and omits "rational and factual" understanding and "present" ability language from Dusky Statute and CALJIC 4.10 constitutional; language aligns with Dusky; no facial invalidity found
Exclusion/admission of evidence at competency hearing (Skidmore rebuttal, parts of Kania/Mills testimony, jail writings) Court properly exercised Evidence Code §352 discretion; writings admissible in surrebuttal; discovery sanctions harmless Exclusion of rebuttal/expert testimony and discovery sanctions violated rights and prejudiced competency finding Rulings largely upheld; any assumed errors were harmless—writings admissible as surrebuttal; overall competency proceeding not fundamentally unfair
Denial of midtrial Faretta self-representation request Denial proper as request was untimely, disruptive, and made to obstruct or delay; court properly exercised Windham discretion Faretta right should be honored; request timely because new audiotape raised issues defendant could not previously present Denial not an abuse of discretion: request untimely and likely to disrupt/delay trial; court permissibly considered multiple Windham factors
Excusal for cause of prospective juror(s) based solely on questionnaire (Witherspoon/Witt) Excusals were proper where questionnaire responses showed inability to follow law and duties Excusing juror B.R. on questionnaire alone was improper; responses were ambiguous and required voir dire Error in excusing B.R. for cause based solely on questionnaire; under Gray v. Mississippi this Witherspoon/Witt error mandates reversal of the penalty judgment

Key Cases Cited

  • Dusky v. United States, 362 U.S. 402 (recognition of competence standard: present ability to consult with counsel with reasonable degree of rational understanding)
  • Drope v. Missouri, 420 U.S. 162 (procedural protections required to avoid trial of an incompetent defendant)
  • Cooper v. Oklahoma, 517 U.S. 348 (standard for competency-related procedural safeguards)
  • Gray v. Mississippi, 481 U.S. 648 (erroneous excusal of juror for cause based on death-penalty views requires automatic reversal of penalty phase)
  • People v. Medina, 51 Cal.3d 870 (competency hearing standards; reversible error where court fails to protect incompetent-defendant rights)
  • People v. Jablonski, 37 Cal.4th 774 (statutory competency language consistent with Dusky)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: People v. Buenrostro
Court Name: California Supreme Court
Date Published: Dec 3, 2018
Citations: 6 Cal. 5th 367; 430 P.3d 1179; 240 Cal. Rptr. 3d 704; S073823
Docket Number: S073823
Court Abbreviation: Cal.
Log In