People ex rel. S.N-V.
2011 Colo. App. LEXIS 2106
| Colo. Ct. App. | 2011Background
- B.A.N. appeals a judgment terminating parental rights to his daughter S.N-V.; the juvenile court terminated after finding unfitness and no less drastic alternative.
- The Department sought termination by clear and convincing evidence, alleging reasonable efforts to rehabilitate had failed.
- The court found the Department’s reasonable efforts were adequate despite not obtaining a full neuropsychological evaluation for father.
- Father argued the Department’s failure to conduct a full neuropsychological evaluation meant services were not appropriately tailored.
- The court found the treatment plan appropriate and that services were insufficient to render father fit within a reasonable time.
- The appellate decision affirms termination and notes a possible placement with S.N-V.’s paternal aunt as a future option for permanence.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether reasonable efforts to rehabilitate were proven. | B.A.N. | Department | Yes; clear and convincing evidence supported reasonable efforts were unsuccessful. |
| Whether estoppel or forfeiture bars appellate review of reasonable efforts. | B.A.N. | Department | No; estoppel/forfeiture do not bar review in termination proceedings. |
| Whether no less drastic alternative exists. | B.A.N. | Department | Yes; permanent placement via adoption was appropriate and no less drastic alternative existed. |
Key Cases Cited
- People in Interest of A.J.L., 243 P.3d 244 (Colo.2010) (credibility and sufficiency review of termination findings; defer to juvenile court on credibility)
- People in Interest of M.S., 129 P.3d 1086 (Colo.App.2005) (invited error/waiver considerations in treatment-plan challenges)
- People in Interest of B.J.D., 626 P.2d 727 (Colo.App.1981) (treatment-plan appropriateness not defeated by lack of objection)
- Santosky v. Kramer, 455 U.S. 745 (U.S.1982) (due process standard and heightened burden in termination hearings)
- A.M.D., 648 P.2d 625 (Colo.1982) (clear and convincing standard in termination proceedings)
