History
  • No items yet
midpage
Neb. Att'y Gen.
2011
Read the full case

Background

  • Nebraska Article III, §12(3) limits legislators to two additional four-year terms after serving two consecutive terms, with partial terms in question.
  • Initiative #415, adopted in 2000, clarifies term-limit calculations for those who fill partial terms.
  • The Secretary of State asks how to apply §12(3) to a senator who filled a partial term, specifically Senator Fulton.
  • Nebraska measures a legislative term by the start of annual sessions, not by calendar days.
  • The Court identifies two methodologies: (a) count days to define half-term; (b) use session-start mid-point in January.
  • The opinion adopts the session-start mid-point approach, concluding Fulton served half a term from 1/3/2007 to 1/7/2009, making him eligible for two more terms.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
What constitutes one-half of a term under §12(3)? Gale favors day-count method. Bruning favors session-start mid-point. Mid-point by session-start date adopted.
Should term half-measurement be calendar-day based or session-based? Gale advocates counting days in original and partial terms. Bruning advocates session-based half-term measurement. Session-based approach selected.
How does the Fulton partial term affect eligibility for future terms? Partial term may count as a full term depending on method. Applying session-based half-term yields Fulton eligible for two more terms. Fulton served half-term; eligible for two additional terms.
Does beginning-date-based half-term align with constitutional intent? Method may complicate eligibility inconsistently. Method consistent with session-based term measurement and eligibility preservation. Approach preserves eligibility and aligns with practice.
What precedent governs calculation of term lengths in Nebraska? Johnson v. Gale provides context but is inconclusive on half-term. Johnson supports session-based measurement and constitutional validity. Johnson v. Gale supports approach; adopts session-based half-term.

Key Cases Cited

  • State ex rel. Johnson v. Gale, 273 Neb. 889 (Neb. 2007) (held constitutionality of §12; discussed term measurement by session dates)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Opinion No. (2011)
Court Name: Nebraska Attorney General Reports
Date Published: Sep 27, 2011
Court Abbreviation: Neb. Att'y Gen.
Log In