Slip Opinion
S.D.N.Y.2016Background
- Plaintiff Al Hajj Ash Sheikh Siraj Abdul Aziz Muhammad, a pro se inmate, was received into DOCCS custody at Downstate on June 26, 2012; Officer Douglas ordered him to remove his beard despite Plaintiff showing a state court order exempting him from DOCCS Directive 4914 (shaving requirement).
- Plaintiff refused, was charged with disobeying a direct order, and placed in pre-hearing keeplock for 10 days; the disciplinary ticket was later dismissed after Plaintiff produced the state court order.
- Plaintiff alleges harms from keeplock: restricted access to religious services, cold meals, segregated recreation, and a knee injury from falling off his bed.
- Plaintiff asserts First Amendment free exercise and § 1983 claims based on Directive 4914 and Officer Douglas’s actions; Defendant moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim and for failure to exhaust administrative remedies under the PLRA.
- The Court declined to convert the motion to summary judgment and accepted pro se factual allegations; it found exhaustion unclear on the face of the complaint but concluded administrative remedies may have been unavailable because Plaintiff alleges he filed a grievance that IGRC could not locate and that CORC had no record.
- On the merits, the Court dismissed Plaintiff’s First Amendment claim (Directive 4914 is reasonably related to penological interests), rejected any federal claim based solely on violation of DOCCS Directive 4914, and held that 10 days of keeplock did not create an atypical and significant hardship under Sandin.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Failure to exhaust administrative remedies under PLRA | Plaintiff alleges he filed an IGRC grievance and sent materials to CORC; IGRC/CORC lost or did not record the grievance | Plaintiff did not complete appeals to CORC and therefore failed to exhaust | Court: Although exhaustion appears incomplete on the face of the complaint, facts plausibly show remedies may have been unavailable (IGRC/CORC had no record); exemption applies — exhaustion excused |
| First Amendment free exercise challenge to Directive 4914 | Directive 4914 substantially burdens his Muslim religious practice by forcing shaving | Directive 4914 is reasonably related to legitimate penological interests (identification/security) | Court: Dismissed — plaintiff cannot state a First Amendment claim because Directive 4914 is reasonably related to penological interests |
| § 1983 claim based on violation of DOCCS Directive 4914 | Officer Douglas violated the DOCCS directive, giving rise to § 1983 liability | Violations of prison directives do not create federal constitutional claims | Court: Dismissed — failure to state a § 1983 claim based solely on violation of a DOCCS directive |
| Due process challenge to pre-hearing keeplock (conditions/duration) | 10 days keeplock caused atypical and significant hardships (religious deprivation, cold meals, segregated rec) and physical injury | 10 days is short; complained conditions are not atypical or severe enough to implicate Sandin liberty interest | Court: Dismissed — 10-day keeplock and alleged conditions do not constitute atypical and significant hardship under Sandin |
Key Cases Cited
- Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 566 U.S. 662 (legal standard for plausibility in Rule 12(b)(6) review)
- Bell Atl. Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (pleading must state a plausible claim)
- Salahuddin v. Goord, 467 F.3d 263 (Turner factors and burden-shifting in prison free-exercise claims)
- Turner v. Safley, 482 U.S. 78 (prison regulations valid if reasonably related to penological interests)
- Sandin v. Conner, 515 U.S. 472 (standard for atypical and significant hardship creating protected liberty interest)
- Hemphill v. New York, 380 F.3d 680 (circumstances excusing PLRA exhaustion)
- Woodford v. Ngo, 548 U.S. 81 (exhaustion doctrine and procedural requirements)