Midland Funding, L.L.C. v. Ogunduyile
2017 Ohio 9314
Ohio Ct. App.2017Background
- Defendant Ayo Ogunduyile opened a Credit One credit-card account in 2011; the account was charged off in 2013 and later purchased by Midland Funding, LLC.
- Midland sued Ogunduyile in 2017 on an account, alleging a balance due of $877.75; Midland did not seek pre-judgment interest.
- Midland attached to its complaint a July 2013 monthly statement showing a $877.75 balance and a chain‑of‑title showing assignment to Midland.
- Ogunduyile was properly served, did not answer, and a default notice and motion for default judgment were filed.
- Midland’s motion included an affidavit from a servicer employee stating the balance remained $877.75 as of February 14, 2017. The trial court entered default judgment for $877.75 plus costs.
- On appeal (pro se) Ogunduyile challenged only the amount, arguing the card’s credit limit was $400 and he should only owe that amount; he did not dispute entry of default judgment.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether default judgment was proper where defendant failed to answer | Midland: default appropriate under Civ.R. 55; complaint and supporting documents establish account balance | Ogunduyile: did not contest default entry (only amount) | Court: No abuse of discretion in entering default judgment when defendant did not defend |
| Whether the alleged $877.75 is a liquidated, provable amount | Midland: complaint, account statement, and servicer affidavit show an ascertainable balance of $877.75 | Ogunduyile: credit limit was $400 so balance cannot be $877.75; prepared to pay $400 | Court: Amount is liquidated/ascertainable; trial court properly relied on complaint and affidavit to award $877.75 |
Key Cases Cited
- Lykins v. Miami Valley Hosp., 811 N.E.2d 124 (Ohio Ct. App. 2004) (Civ.R. 55 permits default judgment when a defendant fails to appear)
- Discover Bank v. Swartz, 51 N.E.3d 694 (Ohio Ct. App. 2016) (credit‑card balance may be liquidated if amount is ascertainable by agreement or arithmetic)
