midpage
Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.
2021
Read the full case

Background

  • Pro se prisoner Brett W. Lutz sued two DOCCS correction officers alleging federal civil-rights claims and state-law assault claims.
  • Defendants moved for summary judgment (and alternatively to dismiss), arguing Lutz failed to exhaust administrative remedies; Magistrate Judge Stewart recommended granting the motion and dismissing state-law claims under N.Y. Corr. Law § 24 or as untimely.
  • Lutz filed two grievances (consolidated) but did not appeal the superintendent’s denial; he argued in objection that Hayes v. Dahlke controls because DOCCS rules allegedly left no clear further step when a superintendent fails to decide within 25 days.
  • Magistrate found Lutz presented no admissible evidence excusing non‑exhaustion (no credible proof of threats, confusion, or procedural impossibility) and noted the rules permitted appeal to CORC by filing Form 2133.
  • The district court reviewed the magistrate’s report (de novo as to the specific objection, clear‑error otherwise), rejected Lutz’s Hayes-based argument as distinguishable, and concluded Lutz unreasonably failed to exhaust available remedies.
  • The court adopted the Report‑Recommendation in full, granted defendants’ motion, dismissed the amended complaint, and found an appeal would not be taken in good faith.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Exhaustion of administrative remedies Hayes applies; DOCCS rules did not clearly require appeal to CORC when superintendent failed to decide, so no further steps were available Lutz filed grievances but did not appeal superintendent's denial to CORC (Form 2133); he therefore failed to exhaust and offers no excuse Summary judgment for defendants: Lutz failed to exhaust; Hayes is distinguishable because the regulations here provided an appeal route (Form 2133)
State‑law assault claims (N.Y. Corr. Law § 24 / timeliness) Claims are viable Claims barred by Correction Law § 24 or untimely Dismissed for failure to state a claim under § 24 and alternatively as untimely

Key Cases Cited

  • Hayes v. Dahlke, 976 F.3d 259 (2d Cir. 2020) (where CORC failed to decide an appeal, there were no further administrative steps and exhaustion was excused)
  • Mario v. P&C Food Markets, Inc., 313 F.3d 758 (2d Cir. 2002) (objections to a magistrate report must be specific to preserve issues for review)
  • Paddington Partners v. Bouchard, 34 F.3d 1132 (2d Cir. 1994) (district court ordinarily will not consider new testimony not offered to the magistrate)
  • Pan Am. World Airways, Inc. v. Int'l Bhd. of Teamsters, 894 F.2d 36 (2d Cir. 1990) (district court may refuse additional testimony absent justification for earlier omission)
  • United States v. Raddatz, 447 U.S. 667 (1980) (de novo review does not require a second evidentiary hearing)
  • Camardo v. Gen. Motors Hourly‑Rate Emp. Pension Plan, 806 F. Supp. 380 (W.D.N.Y. 1992) (re‑hashed arguments in objections need not be considered)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Lutz v. Thoms
Court Name: District Court, N.D. New York
Date Published: Mar 9, 2021
Citations: 2021 WL 868618; 9:20-cv-00240
Docket Number: 9:20-cv-00240
Court Abbreviation: N.D.N.Y.
Log In