Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.2021Background
- Pro se prisoner Brett W. Lutz sued two DOCCS correction officers alleging federal civil-rights claims and state-law assault claims.
- Defendants moved for summary judgment (and alternatively to dismiss), arguing Lutz failed to exhaust administrative remedies; Magistrate Judge Stewart recommended granting the motion and dismissing state-law claims under N.Y. Corr. Law § 24 or as untimely.
- Lutz filed two grievances (consolidated) but did not appeal the superintendent’s denial; he argued in objection that Hayes v. Dahlke controls because DOCCS rules allegedly left no clear further step when a superintendent fails to decide within 25 days.
- Magistrate found Lutz presented no admissible evidence excusing non‑exhaustion (no credible proof of threats, confusion, or procedural impossibility) and noted the rules permitted appeal to CORC by filing Form 2133.
- The district court reviewed the magistrate’s report (de novo as to the specific objection, clear‑error otherwise), rejected Lutz’s Hayes-based argument as distinguishable, and concluded Lutz unreasonably failed to exhaust available remedies.
- The court adopted the Report‑Recommendation in full, granted defendants’ motion, dismissed the amended complaint, and found an appeal would not be taken in good faith.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Exhaustion of administrative remedies | Hayes applies; DOCCS rules did not clearly require appeal to CORC when superintendent failed to decide, so no further steps were available | Lutz filed grievances but did not appeal superintendent's denial to CORC (Form 2133); he therefore failed to exhaust and offers no excuse | Summary judgment for defendants: Lutz failed to exhaust; Hayes is distinguishable because the regulations here provided an appeal route (Form 2133) |
| State‑law assault claims (N.Y. Corr. Law § 24 / timeliness) | Claims are viable | Claims barred by Correction Law § 24 or untimely | Dismissed for failure to state a claim under § 24 and alternatively as untimely |
Key Cases Cited
- Hayes v. Dahlke, 976 F.3d 259 (2d Cir. 2020) (where CORC failed to decide an appeal, there were no further administrative steps and exhaustion was excused)
- Mario v. P&C Food Markets, Inc., 313 F.3d 758 (2d Cir. 2002) (objections to a magistrate report must be specific to preserve issues for review)
- Paddington Partners v. Bouchard, 34 F.3d 1132 (2d Cir. 1994) (district court ordinarily will not consider new testimony not offered to the magistrate)
- Pan Am. World Airways, Inc. v. Int'l Bhd. of Teamsters, 894 F.2d 36 (2d Cir. 1990) (district court may refuse additional testimony absent justification for earlier omission)
- United States v. Raddatz, 447 U.S. 667 (1980) (de novo review does not require a second evidentiary hearing)
- Camardo v. Gen. Motors Hourly‑Rate Emp. Pension Plan, 806 F. Supp. 380 (W.D.N.Y. 1992) (re‑hashed arguments in objections need not be considered)