Leftridge v. Wiggins
44 A.3d 217
Conn. App. Ct.2012Background
- Leftridge appeals a trial court modification increasing child support from $50 to $150 per week.
- State filed motion to modify on behalf of Wiggins; service alleged at 49 Spring Street, Hartford, in care of Sylvontae Bishop.
- July 13, 2010 magistrate vacated prior order, reinstating $50 weekly support due to lack of proper jurisdiction.
- September 27, 2010 hearing on modification held; Leftridge allegedly not served, though notice appeared to have been mailed.
- Court found notice of September 27, 2010 proceedings and retroactive modification to May 28, 2010; Leftridge challenged notice.
- On appeal, court reversed, holding Leftridge was not properly served and thus denied due process.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Was Leftridge properly served with the motion to modify? | Leftridge did not receive proper service of the motion to modify. | Service was proper or substantially valid; notice was adequate. | No; service was defective, violating due process. |
| Did the September 27, 2010 orders violate due process due to lack of notice? | Without proper service he had no meaningful opportunity to be heard. | The record shows notice and Leftridge had some awareness of proceedings. | Yes; due process violated; orders must be vacated. |
| May the modification be retroactive under § 46b-86 where pending motion existed? | Retroactive modification without proper service is improper. | Statutory retroactivity applies since modification was pending. | Modification improperly retroactive; vacate orders. |
Key Cases Cited
- Winick v. Winick, 153 Conn. 294 (Conn. 1965) (due process requires notice and opportunity to be heard)
- Pritchard v. Pritchard, 103 Conn. App. 276 (Conn. App. 2007) (fundamental notice and opportunity to be heard in family support matters)
- Waterview Site Services, Inc. v. Pay Day, Inc., 125 Conn.App. 561 (Conn. App. 2010) (clear error standard for trial court factual findings; notice issues)
