397 P.3d 1181
Kan.2017Background
- Shane Landrum, charged with first-degree murder, is represented by privately retained counsel and was declared partially indigent by a prior district judge.
- Landrum sought funding for transcripts and investigative services from the State Board of Indigents' Defense Services (BIDS) under K.S.A. 22-4508; some earlier requests were granted.
- Presiding Judge Jeffrey Goering denied later requests, ruling that only court-appointed counsel (not retained counsel) may access BIDS payments, citing Morrow v. State and Board regulations.
- Landrum petitioned the Kansas Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus directing the district court to hold an ex parte hearing under K.S.A. 22-4508.
- The Kansas Supreme Court accepted the Board as intervenor and addressed whether K.S.A. 22-4508 permits privately retained counsel to seek BIDS-funded services for partially indigent defendants.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether K.S.A. 22-4508 allows retained counsel to request BIDS-funded services via ex parte application | Landrum: statute’s phrase "an attorney other than a public defender" includes privately retained counsel; BIDS funds available if defendant cannot afford necessary services | Board/Judge Goering: statute and related provisions/regulations mean only appointed/contract counsel may access BIDS; retained counsel excluded | Court: Statute’s plain language covers any attorney other than a public defender, including retained counsel; district court must hold ex parte hearing |
| Proper financial test for eligibility under K.S.A. 22-4508 | Landrum: eligibility focuses on defendant's inability to obtain necessary services, not inability to hire counsel | Board: eligibility should be tied to inability to employ counsel (per other provisions) to prevent abuse | Court: K.S.A. 22-4508 uses a distinct test — inability to obtain necessary services — and does not require inability to employ counsel |
| Persuasiveness of Morrow v. State as controlling precedent | Landrum: Morrow is inapplicable because it involved different statute and misapplied interpretive rules | Board: Morrow supports limiting BIDS payments to cases with appointed counsel | Court: Declines to follow Morrow; finds it unpersuasive and not aligned with current statutory interpretation rules |
| Scope of mandamus relief — can the court dictate outcome of ex parte hearing | Landrum: asks court to order Board to pay for services | Respondents: discretion belongs to district court and eligibility can be reviewed | Court: Grants mandamus in part — orders ex parte hearing but will not direct the substantive outcome; district court must independently assess finances and necessity |
Key Cases Cited
- Morrow v. State, 18 Kan. App. 2d 236 (1993) (Court of Appeals decision relied on by district court but deemed inapplicable here)
- State v. Becker, 264 Kan. 804 (1998) (mandamus is extraordinary remedy; standards discussed)
- In re Marriage of Brown, 295 Kan. 966 (2012) (statutory interpretation: start with plain language)
- Douglas v. Ad Astra Information Systems, 296 Kan. 552 (2013) (rejecting doctrine of operative construction; courts perform independent statutory interpretation)
- Ft. Hays State Univ. v. University Chapter, Am. Ass'n of Univ. Profs., 290 Kan. 446 (2010) (deference to agency interpretation limited)
- Ambrosier v. Brown, 304 Kan. 907 (2016) (principles on exercising original mandamus jurisdiction)
- State ex rel. Stephan v. Kansas House of Representatives, 236 Kan. 45 (1984) (mandamus appropriate to obtain authoritative interpretation for public officials)