midpage
397 P.3d 1181
Kan.
2017

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Shane Landrum, charged with first-degree murder, is represented by privately retained counsel and was declared partially indigent by a prior district judge.
  • Landrum sought funding for transcripts and investigative services from the State Board of Indigents' Defense Services (BIDS) under K.S.A. 22-4508; some earlier requests were granted.
  • Presiding Judge Jeffrey Goering denied later requests, ruling that only court-appointed counsel (not retained counsel) may access BIDS payments, citing Morrow v. State and Board regulations.
  • Landrum petitioned the Kansas Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus directing the district court to hold an ex parte hearing under K.S.A. 22-4508.
  • The Kansas Supreme Court accepted the Board as intervenor and addressed whether K.S.A. 22-4508 permits privately retained counsel to seek BIDS-funded services for partially indigent defendants.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether K.S.A. 22-4508 allows retained counsel to request BIDS-funded services via ex parte application Landrum: statute’s phrase "an attorney other than a public defender" includes privately retained counsel; BIDS funds available if defendant cannot afford necessary services Board/Judge Goering: statute and related provisions/regulations mean only appointed/contract counsel may access BIDS; retained counsel excluded Court: Statute’s plain language covers any attorney other than a public defender, including retained counsel; district court must hold ex parte hearing
Proper financial test for eligibility under K.S.A. 22-4508 Landrum: eligibility focuses on defendant's inability to obtain necessary services, not inability to hire counsel Board: eligibility should be tied to inability to employ counsel (per other provisions) to prevent abuse Court: K.S.A. 22-4508 uses a distinct test — inability to obtain necessary services — and does not require inability to employ counsel
Persuasiveness of Morrow v. State as controlling precedent Landrum: Morrow is inapplicable because it involved different statute and misapplied interpretive rules Board: Morrow supports limiting BIDS payments to cases with appointed counsel Court: Declines to follow Morrow; finds it unpersuasive and not aligned with current statutory interpretation rules
Scope of mandamus relief — can the court dictate outcome of ex parte hearing Landrum: asks court to order Board to pay for services Respondents: discretion belongs to district court and eligibility can be reviewed Court: Grants mandamus in part — orders ex parte hearing but will not direct the substantive outcome; district court must independently assess finances and necessity

Key Cases Cited

  • Morrow v. State, 18 Kan. App. 2d 236 (1993) (Court of Appeals decision relied on by district court but deemed inapplicable here)
  • State v. Becker, 264 Kan. 804 (1998) (mandamus is extraordinary remedy; standards discussed)
  • In re Marriage of Brown, 295 Kan. 966 (2012) (statutory interpretation: start with plain language)
  • Douglas v. Ad Astra Information Systems, 296 Kan. 552 (2013) (rejecting doctrine of operative construction; courts perform independent statutory interpretation)
  • Ft. Hays State Univ. v. University Chapter, Am. Ass'n of Univ. Profs., 290 Kan. 446 (2010) (deference to agency interpretation limited)
  • Ambrosier v. Brown, 304 Kan. 907 (2016) (principles on exercising original mandamus jurisdiction)
  • State ex rel. Stephan v. Kansas House of Representatives, 236 Kan. 45 (1984) (mandamus appropriate to obtain authoritative interpretation for public officials)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Landrum v. Goering
Court Name: Supreme Court of Kansas
Date Published: Jul 21, 2017
Citations: 397 P.3d 1181; 306 Kan. 867; 116447
Docket Number: 116447
Court Abbreviation: Kan.
Log In