midpage
Slip Opinion
S.D.N.Y.
2019
Read the full case

Background

  • Plaintiff Lionel Michael King, a pro se inmate, alleges that on Sept. 15, 2015 at Sullivan CF officers assaulted him, removed his clothing, and that Nurse Carol Chiocchi provided inadequate medical care (only Tylenol and a blood-pressure check).
  • King filed three DOCCS grievances (expedited "code 49" staff-misconduct grievances) that the facility superintendent denied.
  • There is no record that King appealed any of the three superintendent denials to the Central Office Review Committee (CORC).
  • Defendants moved for summary judgment primarily on PLRA exhaustion grounds; they also sought merits dismissal as to the medical-care claim.
  • In opposing summary judgment King later alleged a more specific sexual-assault claim not pleaded in the complaint.
  • The Court granted summary judgment dismissing the physical-assault and inadequate-medical-care claims for failure to exhaust administrative remedies, declined to consider the unpled sexual-assault allegations now raised for the first time in opposition, but allowed King 30 days to file an amended complaint to assert a sexual-assault claim.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether King exhausted administrative remedies for his physical-assault and inadequate-medical-care claims under the PLRA/DOCCS IGP King contends he filed grievances and complained to outside authorities; he also says he did not receive responses from the grievance supervisor Defendants show three grievances were filed, superintendent decisions denied them, and there is no record King appealed to CORC Court: King did not properly exhaust; claims dismissed for failure to exhaust
Whether an exception to exhaustion (availability under Ross v. Blake) applies King asserts process was effectively unavailable (and later argues sexual-assault reporting rules may apply) Defendants show King successfully exhausted many other grievances in the past and that superintendent decisions were delivered Court: no Ross exception; IGP was available to King
Whether the Court may consider the sexual-assault allegations King raised only in opposition to summary judgment King argues he was sexually assaulted and (invoking Directive 4040) that such reports satisfy PLRA exhaustion Defendants argue the sexual-assault theory is new, not pleaded, and defendants lack notice; consideration now would be prejudicial Court: sexual-assault claim is unpled and not considered on summary judgment, but King is granted leave to amend and plead that claim within 30 days
Whether the court resolved Nurse Chiocchi’s medical-care claim on the merits King alleges deliberate indifference/ inadequate care (Tylenol only, false notes) Defendants moved on both exhaustion and merits as to Chiocchi Court resolved the case on exhaustion grounds and dismissed the medical-care claim for failure to exhaust; it did not reach a merits judgment on the medical claim

Key Cases Cited

  • Ross v. Blake, 136 S. Ct. 1850 (2016) (exhaustion requirement is mandatory but hinges on availability of administrative remedies)
  • Booth v. Churner, 532 U.S. 731 (2001) (PLRA exhaustion applies even when requested relief is unavailable administratively)
  • Porter v. Nussle, 534 U.S. 516 (2002) (PLRA exhaustion applies to all inmate suits about prison life)
  • Williams v. Priatno, 829 F.3d 118 (2d Cir. 2016) (requires proper/strict exhaustion using all steps prison grievance system provides)
  • Colon v. Coughlin, 58 F.3d 865 (2d Cir. 1995) (verified pro se complaint may be treated as affidavit for summary-judgment purposes)
  • Scott v. Harris, 550 U.S. 372 (2007) (court need not accept a version of events blatantly contradicted by the record)
  • Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574 (1986) (nonmovant must present specific evidence to raise a genuine issue for trial)
  • Jeffreys v. City of New York, 426 F.3d 549 (2d Cir. 2005) (district courts may not weigh credibility or resolve factual issues on summary judgment)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: King v. Puershner
Court Name: District Court, S.D. New York
Date Published: Sep 18, 2019
Citations: 2019 WL 4519692; 7:17-cv-01373
Docket Number: 7:17-cv-01373
Court Abbreviation: S.D.N.Y.
Log In