Slip Opinion
S.D.N.Y.2019Background
- Plaintiff Lionel Michael King, a pro se inmate, alleges that on Sept. 15, 2015 at Sullivan CF officers assaulted him, removed his clothing, and that Nurse Carol Chiocchi provided inadequate medical care (only Tylenol and a blood-pressure check).
- King filed three DOCCS grievances (expedited "code 49" staff-misconduct grievances) that the facility superintendent denied.
- There is no record that King appealed any of the three superintendent denials to the Central Office Review Committee (CORC).
- Defendants moved for summary judgment primarily on PLRA exhaustion grounds; they also sought merits dismissal as to the medical-care claim.
- In opposing summary judgment King later alleged a more specific sexual-assault claim not pleaded in the complaint.
- The Court granted summary judgment dismissing the physical-assault and inadequate-medical-care claims for failure to exhaust administrative remedies, declined to consider the unpled sexual-assault allegations now raised for the first time in opposition, but allowed King 30 days to file an amended complaint to assert a sexual-assault claim.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether King exhausted administrative remedies for his physical-assault and inadequate-medical-care claims under the PLRA/DOCCS IGP | King contends he filed grievances and complained to outside authorities; he also says he did not receive responses from the grievance supervisor | Defendants show three grievances were filed, superintendent decisions denied them, and there is no record King appealed to CORC | Court: King did not properly exhaust; claims dismissed for failure to exhaust |
| Whether an exception to exhaustion (availability under Ross v. Blake) applies | King asserts process was effectively unavailable (and later argues sexual-assault reporting rules may apply) | Defendants show King successfully exhausted many other grievances in the past and that superintendent decisions were delivered | Court: no Ross exception; IGP was available to King |
| Whether the Court may consider the sexual-assault allegations King raised only in opposition to summary judgment | King argues he was sexually assaulted and (invoking Directive 4040) that such reports satisfy PLRA exhaustion | Defendants argue the sexual-assault theory is new, not pleaded, and defendants lack notice; consideration now would be prejudicial | Court: sexual-assault claim is unpled and not considered on summary judgment, but King is granted leave to amend and plead that claim within 30 days |
| Whether the court resolved Nurse Chiocchi’s medical-care claim on the merits | King alleges deliberate indifference/ inadequate care (Tylenol only, false notes) | Defendants moved on both exhaustion and merits as to Chiocchi | Court resolved the case on exhaustion grounds and dismissed the medical-care claim for failure to exhaust; it did not reach a merits judgment on the medical claim |
Key Cases Cited
- Ross v. Blake, 136 S. Ct. 1850 (2016) (exhaustion requirement is mandatory but hinges on availability of administrative remedies)
- Booth v. Churner, 532 U.S. 731 (2001) (PLRA exhaustion applies even when requested relief is unavailable administratively)
- Porter v. Nussle, 534 U.S. 516 (2002) (PLRA exhaustion applies to all inmate suits about prison life)
- Williams v. Priatno, 829 F.3d 118 (2d Cir. 2016) (requires proper/strict exhaustion using all steps prison grievance system provides)
- Colon v. Coughlin, 58 F.3d 865 (2d Cir. 1995) (verified pro se complaint may be treated as affidavit for summary-judgment purposes)
- Scott v. Harris, 550 U.S. 372 (2007) (court need not accept a version of events blatantly contradicted by the record)
- Matsushita Elec. Indus. Co. v. Zenith Radio Corp., 475 U.S. 574 (1986) (nonmovant must present specific evidence to raise a genuine issue for trial)
- Jeffreys v. City of New York, 426 F.3d 549 (2d Cir. 2005) (district courts may not weigh credibility or resolve factual issues on summary judgment)