KAZ Construction, Inc. v. Newport Equity Partners
229 Ariz. 303
Ariz. Ct. App.2012Background
- Sierra Cobre Estates property (lots 1-56) in Cochise County is at issue; TSA Trust 1025 holds title with Zanderholm as beneficiary.
- Zanderholm directed TSA to handle the property; TSA owns legal title; Zanderholm retains a right to profits from sales.
- In 2007, Strohbachs loaned Zanderholm $1.98 million, secured by a deed of trust naming the Strohbachs as beneficiaries; TSA not a party.
- KAZ proposed site work (Feb 2008); TSA did not sign; 20-day notice to Trust 1025 and Newport, but not to Strohbachs.
- KAZ recorded a notice and lien in June 2008; Strohbachs seek to invalidate KAZ lien and assert priority of their deed.
- Trial court granted summary judgment for KAZ, declaring Strohbachs’ deed invalid and KAZ lien valid first position; appeal followed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Authority to encumber by beneficiary | Strohbachs: Zanderholm could encumber property under trust terms. | KAZ: TSA must convey; Zanderholm lacked authority per trust terms. | Strohbachs' deed invalid; Zanderholm had no encumbrance power. |
| Validity of KAZ's mechanic's lien against Strohbachs | Strohbachs: Notice served to trust lender not required; lien valid. | KAZ: Twenty-day notice to construction lender required; notice insufficient or improper. | KAZ lien invalid as to Strohbachs; notice requirement violated. |
Key Cases Cited
- Lane Title & Trust Co. v. Brannan, 103 Ariz. 272 (Ariz. 1968) (trust governed by instrument and general trust law)
- Dunlap Investors Ltd. v. Hogan, 133 Ariz. 130 (Ariz. 1982) (beneficiary may encumber absent contrary agreement)
- In re Herbst, 206 Ariz. 214 (Ariz. 2003) (trust terms govern extent of beneficiary interest)
- Watson Constr. Co. v. Amfac Mortg. Corp., 124 Ariz. 570 (App. 1979) (recorded deed of trust provides constructive notice)
- Delmastro & Eells v. Taco Bell Corp., 228 Ariz. 134 (App. 2011) (purpose of notice statute to ensure payment and communication)
