History
  • No items yet
midpage
320 Conn. 1
Conn.
2015
Read the full case

Background

  • Defendant Mendez executed a promissory note for $296,000 secured by a mortgage on 45 Derek Lane, Windsor.
  • Plaintiff JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A. acquired the note and mortgage; default was declared in 2012.
  • Trial court entered default against Mendez on September 19, 2013, and ordered a judgment of foreclosure by sale for September 30, 2013.
  • A public foreclosure sale occurred January 11, 2014; plaintiff was the sole bidder and winner.
  • Mendez first appeared January 14, 2014 and moved to open and vacate the judgment of foreclosure by sale under § 49-15.
  • Trial court denied the motion, concluding § 52-212 governs, § 49-15 applies to strict foreclosures, and equity did not justify opening the judgment; appellate court transferred and held moot, dismissing the appeal.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether the appeal is moot and justiciable Mendez argues to reach §52-212 vs §49-15 issues. Appellate review should proceed since equity could provide relief. Appeal dismissed as moot; no practical relief available.
Proper statutory basis for opening a foreclosure by sale judgment §52-212 governs opening of judgments; §49-15 is inapplicable to sale judgments. §49-15 applies to opening judgments, including foreclosure by sale. Moot; court did not reach merits, but reflects §52-212 applicability per court's moot ruling.

Key Cases Cited

  • Wyatt Energy, Inc. v. Motiva Enterprises, LLC, 308 Conn. 719 (2013) (mootness and unreviewable issues; practical relief required)
  • Gagne v. Vaccaro, 311 Conn. 649 (2014) (recusal issue moot due to unchallenged ruling)
  • Valvo v. Freedom of Information Comm'n, 294 Conn. 534 (2010) (threshold mootness and justiciability doctrine)
  • Moraski v. Connecticut Board of Examiners of Embalmers & Funeral Directors, 291 Conn. 242 (2009) (mootness and practical relief considerations)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: JP Morgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. Mendez
Court Name: Supreme Court of Connecticut
Date Published: Dec 22, 2015
Citations: 320 Conn. 1; 127 A.3d 994; SC19481
Docket Number: SC19481
Court Abbreviation: Conn.
Log In