Johnson v. Ware
313 Ga. App. 774
Ga. Ct. App.2012Background
- Two divorced parents dispute custody and visitation for their child; no divorce decree/settlement in record.
- Ware filed a 2009 action seeking modified visitation and a specific parenting plan; Johnson counterclaimed for custody changes.
- Ware later amended to seek primary physical custody; Johnson reasserted custody in a separate action.
- The two actions were tried together by agreement, but there is no trial transcript available.
- The court awarded Ware primary physical custody with a detailed parenting plan and Johnson visitation; Johnson’s action was denied on custody and contempt.
- Post-trial, Johnson filed multiple motions; in 2011, the court denied a Narrative Transcript and issued findings; Johnson appealed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the trial court properly modified custodial rights | Johnson argues the court impermissibly modified his custody | Ware contends modification was permissible under the pleadings | No reversible error due to lack of record and pleadings not fully shown |
| Whether the trial court properly admitted all evidence | Johnson claims trial court excluded evidence | No transcript to verify exclusion; witnesses discussed were redundant | Record insufficient to show error; no proven exclusion of testimony |
| Whether child-support findings complied with OCGA | Johnson disputes missing child support worksheet and outside-tuition payments | Ware concedes deficiencies; deviations require explanation | Remand for proper findings and compliance with child-support guidelines |
Key Cases Cited
- Holloway v. Holloway, 288 Ga. 147 (Ga. 2010) (mandatory findings under child-support guidelines where applicable)
- Turner v. Turner, 285 Ga. 866 (Ga. 2009) (mandatory findings; deviations in tuition require explanation)
- White v. Regions Bank, 275 Ga. 38 (Ga. 2002) (exclusion of cumulative evidence not an abuse of discretion)
- Roberts v. Windsor Credit Svcs., 301 Ga.App. 393 (Ga. App. 2009) (burden to show error by record; lack of transcript defeats appeal)
