491 B.R. 580
Bankr. M.D. Fla.2012Background
- Debtor and non-filing spouse owned sale proceeds of real property as tenants by the entirety; proceeds deposited in spouse's name.
- Debtor filed for Chapter 7; Trustee (creditor of only Debtor) pursued fraudulent transfer claim to recover 50% of proceeds.
- New Jersey enacted N.J. Stat. §§ 46:3-17.2 to 46:3-17.4 in 1988 to treat certain personal property as held in entirety.
- Deed describing spouses as 'Manuel Montemoino and Elsie Montemoino, his wife' created tenancy by the entirety for real property.
- Check for sale proceeds payable to 'Manuel Montemoino and Elsie Montemoino' and deposited solely in non-debtor spouse’s account.
- Court must decide if New Jersey law allows a creditor of one spouse to reach entireties property.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Can a creditor of one spouse reach entireties proceeds? | Trustee contends proceeds are debtor-spouse property. | Proceeds are held by entirety and immune to one-spouse creditor. | No reach; proceeds treated as entireties property immune to single-spouse creditors. |
| Are the sale proceeds property of the estate for exemptions? | Debtor may exempt 50% of proceeds under § 522(b)(3)(B). | Proceeds were not estate property due to pre-petition transfer. | Not applicable; proceeds not property of the estate at petition. |
| Do New Jersey 1988 amendments permit creditor protection for entireties personal property? | Law should allow creditors to reach entireties property. | Statutes protect entireties assets and bar single-spouse creditor claims. | Statutes shield entireties property from single-spouse creditors. |
Key Cases Cited
- King v. Greene, 30 N.J. 395 (N.J. 1959) (prior to statutes, judgment creditors could levy survivorship rights)
- Newman v. Chase, 70 N.J. 254 (N.J. 1976) (one-spouse creditor could reach entireties and create tenancy in common)
- Freda v. Commercial Trust Co. of New Jersey, 570 A.2d 414 (N.J. 1990) (pre-statute decision; recognized protection of entireties but limited by timing)
