Jennifer Jo Broadous v. Commonwealth of Virginia
67 Va. App. 265
| Va. Ct. App. | 2017Background
- On April 3, 2015 Broadous overdosed on fentanyl in a Chesapeake motel; boyfriend William Green called 911 and emergency personnel revived her.
- Broadous admitted recent drug use, consented to a room search, identified a syringe and a “drug kit,” and was transported to the hospital after revival.
- A grand jury indicted Broadous for possession of a Schedule I/II controlled substance (fentanyl) under Va. Code § 18.2-250; she pleaded not guilty and requested a bench trial with stipulated facts.
- Broadous moved to apply the affirmative defense in Va. Code § 18.2-251.03 (immunity for those who “seek or obtain” emergency medical attention for overdoses); the court reserved and later denied the motion.
- The circuit court ruled § 18.2-251.03 did not apply because Broadous neither sought nor actively obtained medical attention; she passively received treatment after Green called 911.
- Broadous was convicted and sentenced; she appealed, arguing “obtains” should cover passive recipients of emergency care.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether § 18.2-251.03(B)(1)’s phrase “seeks or obtains emergency medical attention” covers an overdose victim who passively received care after someone else called 911 | Broadous: “Obtains” is broad/disjunctive and need not require volitional act; passive receipt of care qualifies | Commonwealth: “Seeks or obtains” are active verbs requiring the protected person to take steps to secure care; passive receipt does not qualify | Court: “Obtains” is unambiguous and requires active steps; statute protects the person who sought/obtained care (here, Green), not the passive victim; conviction affirmed |
Key Cases Cited
- Boynton v. Kilgore, 271 Va. 220 (statutory language interpreted by plain meaning)
- Blake v. Commonwealth, 288 Va. 375 (statutory construction and de novo review explained)
- Moreno v. Commonwealth, 65 Va. App. 121 (courts may not add language to statutes)
