Jackson v. Friedlander
2016 Ohio 7503
| Ohio Ct. App. | 2016Background
- Laura Jackson, administratrix of Larry Jackson's estate, sued Dr. Ira Friedlander, Ohio Physicians Professional Corporation, and Aultman Hospital for wrongful death alleging negligent post‑operative care after a pacemaker implantation at Aultman (Stark County); decedent died in Wayne County of a pulmonary embolism after discharge.
- Defendants moved to transfer venue from Wayne County to Stark County; the Wayne County Common Pleas Court granted the transfer and sent the case to Stark County.
- Jackson filed a motion in Stark County to reject the change of venue, arguing wrongful death "part of the claim" arose in Wayne County because the decedent died there; the Stark trial court denied the motion.
- The case proceeded to jury trial in Stark County; the jury returned a verdict for defendants and judgment was entered in February 2016.
- On appeal, Jackson challenged only the venue transfer and asked the appellate court to reverse and remand with instructions to transfer the case back to Wayne County.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the venue transfer from Wayne to Stark was erroneous in a wrongful‑death action where decedent died in Wayne County | Jackson: Wrongful‑death claim "part of the claim" arose in Wayne County because death occurred there, so venue in Wayne was proper and transfer was improper | Defs: Civil Rule 3(G) prohibits voiding a final judgment solely on venue grounds and limits appeals based solely on venue | The appeal, which attacked only venue and sought to void the final judgment, was barred by Civ.R. 3(G); court affirmed Stark County judgment |
Key Cases Cited
- State ex rel. Lyons v. Zaleski, 75 Ohio St.3d 623 (Ohio 1996) (denial or grant of change of venue is not a final, appealable order)
- LaNeve v. Atlas Recycling, Inc., 119 Ohio St.3d 324 (Ohio 2008) (civil rules are not mere technicalities and must be applied according to plain language)
