midpage
27 I. & N. Dec. 420
BIA
2018

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Respondent: LPR from the Dominican Republic; convictions in 1993 (attempted criminal sale, NY Penal Law §220.39 attempt) and 2016 (criminal possession, NY Penal Law §220.16(12)).
  • Immigration Judge (IJ) found respondent removable under INA §237(a)(2)(A)(i) for a crime involving moral turpitude (based on the drug-sale attempt) and denied cancellation of removal and former §212(c) relief.
  • While appeal to the Board was pending, the respondent obtained New York appellate permission to file a late appeal of the 2016 conviction and argued that a direct appeal pending in state court means the conviction is not "final" for immigration purposes, restoring eligibility for former §212(c).
  • The Board affirmed that the 1993 attempted sale offense is categorically a crime involving moral turpitude under the categorical approach (intent/knowledge + inherently reprehensible conduct).
  • The Board considered whether the IIRIRA statutory definition of "conviction" (INA §101(a)(48)(A)) eliminated the pre-IIRIRA rule that a conviction is not final for immigration purposes until direct appeals are exhausted or waived.
  • Because respondent produced evidence that a timely (late) direct appeal had been permitted, the Board remanded to the IJ to examine the appeal's status and basis and to allow further evidence/argument.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument (Respondent) Defendant's Argument (DHS) Held
Finality: whether a conviction is "final" for immigration purposes while a direct appeal is pending The 2016 conviction is not final because a direct appeal was filed within the appeal period (late leave granted), so it cannot be used to support removability or to bar §212(c) relief IIRIRA’s definition of "conviction" makes a trial-court judgment sufficient; the historic finality rule no longer applies Board: The long‑standing finality rule survives IIRIRA; conviction is not final until direct appellate review exhausted or waived, but presumption of finality arises once appeal period lapses; respondent rebutted presumption—remand to IJ to evaluate appeal status and merits
Categorical determination: whether attempted sale of a controlled substance is a crime involving moral turpitude Respondent: offense may not be moral turpitude (e.g., medicinal sales, lack of reprehensible intent) DHS/IJ: sale/distribution of controlled substances involves reprehensible conduct and requires knowledge/intent; attempt shares mens rea Board: Affirmed IJ—attempted sale categorically involves moral turpitude (knowledge/intent + inherently reprehensible conduct)
Eligibility for cancellation of removal under INA §240A(a) (continuous residence) Respondent argued eligibility DHS: 1993 conviction interrupted continuous residence Board: Affirmed denial—respondent failed to show 7 years continuous residence after admission due to 1993 conviction
Effect of non-merits post-conviction actions (e.g., sentence appeals, rehabilitative vacaturs) on immigration finality Respondent argued pending state appeals/court actions eliminate conviction for immigration purposes DHS: Only vacaturs based on merits/procedural defects in underlying conviction should negate conviction; rehabilitative or sentence-only challenges do not Board: Appeals or collateral attacks that do not challenge merits will not negate finality; vacaturs on legal merits will remove immigration effect

Key Cases Cited

  • Pino v. Landon, 349 U.S. 901 (1955) (Supreme Court reversing deportation where record did not show conviction had attained finality)
  • Puello v. Bureau of Citizenship & Immigration Servs., 511 F.3d 324 (2d Cir. 2007) (dicta: IIRIRA eliminated requirement that direct appeals be exhausted)
  • Walcott v. Chertoff, 517 F.3d 149 (2d Cir. 2008) (accepting that conviction was not final for immigration purposes until direct appellate review exhausted)
  • Orabi v. U.S. Attorney General, 738 F.3d 535 (3d Cir. 2014) (holding finality requirement survives IIRIRA—direct appeals must be exhausted or waived)
  • United States v. Garcia-Echaverria, 374 F.3d 440 (6th Cir. 2004) (treating conviction as not final absent exhaustion or waiver of direct appeal)
  • Planes v. Holder, 652 F.3d 991 (9th Cir. 2011) (interpreting §101(a)(48)(A) to require only trial-court judgment of guilt; concluding IIRIRA eliminated finality requirement)
  • Montenegro v. Ashcroft, 355 F.3d 1035 (7th Cir. 2004) (holding conviction was final for immigration purposes despite pending post-conviction petitions)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: J. M. ACOSTA
Court Name: Board of Immigration Appeals
Date Published: Jul 1, 2018
Citations: 27 I. & N. Dec. 420; ID
Docket Number: ID
Court Abbreviation: BIA
Log In