315 Ga. 723
Ga.2023Background
- In Feb 2019 a client retained Kara Sherrisse Lawrence for immigration work under a $3,500 flat-fee retainer authorizing debits from the client’s bank account.
- Lawrence debited the client multiple times (totaling $5,351.75), including a March 5, 2019 debit made without advance notice and exceeding the authorized $3,500.
- Lawrence never successfully entered an appearance in the USCIS portal, made no filings for the client, and her office provided invalid authorization codes; she later abandoned her office and left no contact information.
- The client filed a grievance; Lawrence responded inaccurately (misnaming the client as "Mr. Bennett") and produced no supporting evidence or trust-account records; she failed to comply with Bar requests and the subsequent Notice of Investigation.
- The State Bar filed a formal complaint (served by publication); Lawrence failed to answer, the special master entered default, found multiple GRPC violations, and recommended disbarment; the Supreme Court of Georgia agreed and ordered disbarment.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Improper fee withdrawals / trust-account violations (GRPC 1.15) | Lawrence withdrew client funds without proper authorization or accounting and exceeded the flat fee. | Lawrence offered no credible documentation; in prior grievance she suggested client refused to accept representation. | Defaulted findings establish violations; misconduct supports maximum sanction. |
| Abandonment / failure to prosecute client matter (GRPC 1.2, 1.3, 1.4, 1.16) | Lawrence never entered appearance, made no filings, and abandoned the client despite assurances. | Lawrence did not meaningfully contest the allegations; no evidence of effective representation. | Court found abandonment and failure to represent client. |
| Dishonesty and failure to cooperate with disciplinary process (GRPC 8.1, 8.4, 9.3) | Lawrence misrepresented status of the case to client, misidentified the client in Bar response, and refused to provide records or respond to Bar. | Lawrence provided a deficient oath/response referencing the wrong client and otherwise failed to comply. | Court found dishonest conduct and bad-faith obstruction of disciplinary process. |
| Appropriate sanction (disbarment vs lesser discipline) | Disbarment is appropriate given intentional misconduct, harm to client, pattern of misconduct, and failure to cooperate. | Mitigation: no prior discipline and limited experience. | Court agreed with special master and disbarred Lawrence. |
Key Cases Cited
- In the Matter of Morse, 266 Ga. 652 (consideration of ABA Standards for Imposing Lawyer Sanctions)
- In the Matter of Bell, 313 Ga. 615 (disbarment where attorney abandoned clients and failed to respond to disciplinary authorities)
- In the Matter of Powell, 310 Ga. 859 (disbarment for client abandonment and failure to cooperate)
- In the Matter of Bennett, 307 Ga. 679 (disbarment for similar misconduct and noncompliance)
- In the Matter of Annis, 306 Ga. 187 (disbarment where attorney abandoned clients)
- In the Matter of Miller, 302 Ga. 366 (disbarment for client abandonment and related misconduct)
