midpage
258 N.C. App. 441
N.C. Ct. App.
2018

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Child removed in 2010 after mother (Respondent) left him with a stranger; mother has bipolar I, multiple hospitalizations, and history of substance use tied to mood episodes.
  • Child placed with petitioners (friends/kin) in 2010; petitioners obtained legal custody in 2012 and the child remained with them; petitioners filed to terminate mother's parental rights in 2016.
  • Petition alleged three statutory grounds: neglect (G.S. §7B-1111(a)(1)), willful failure to make reasonable progress for 12+ months (G.S. §7B-1111(a)(2)), and dependency/incapacity (G.S. §7B-1111(a)(6)).
  • Trial court terminated parental rights in May 2017 based on findings concerning the mother’s mental-health episodes, concerning behavior during visits, and the petitioners’ long familiarity with her instability.
  • On appeal, the Court of Appeals reversed, holding the trial court’s findings were not sufficiently specific or temporally connected to support termination on any alleged ground; evidence showed the mother had been symptom-free and stable for ~15 months before the hearing.

Issues

Issue Petitioners' Argument Respondent's Argument Held
Whether respondent failed to make reasonable progress (G.S. §7B-1111(a)(2)) Long history of mental-health episodes, concerning visit behavior, and inability to parent despite ACT services show failure to make reasonable progress over years Mother had been stable and symptom-free for ~15 months, engaged in ACT, housed, employed, sober; trial court findings lacked specificity and recent detail Reversed — findings insufficiently specific/time-linked to show failure to make reasonable progress as of hearing
Whether child would likely be neglected if returned (G.S. §7B-1111(a)(1)) Past neglect and disturbing visit behavior show reasonable probability of repetition Petitioners’ examples were dated and episodic; no clear, convincing evidence of present inability to parent or risk of repetition at time of hearing Reversed — findings too vague and remote in time to show likelihood of future neglect
Whether respondent is currently incapable and will remain so (dependency, G.S. §7B-1111(a)(6)) Mother’s long-term mental illness and need for intensive ACT services render her incapable of providing proper care and lacking alternative child-care Evidence from treating psychiatrist showed stability, insight, adherence to treatment, good prognosis; findings did not describe current incapacity or foreseeability Reversed — findings did not establish present incapacity that will continue for foreseeable future
Sufficiency of trial-court findings generally (due process / appellate review) Trial court properly credited petitioners’ long observation and accepted their testimony; findings warranted termination Findings lacked detail about recent conduct, nature/frequency of "episodes," and relationship between behaviors and parental ability; appellate review requires specific evidentiary findings Reversed — appellate court: ultimate findings not supported by adequate, specific evidentiary findings; remand not warranted because termination order reversed

Key Cases Cited

  • In re C.J.H., 240 N.C. App. 489 (clear, cogent, and convincing standard for termination)
  • In re O.C. & O.B., 171 N.C. App. 457 (two-part test for §7B-1111(a)(2): willful 12+ months and lack of reasonable progress as of hearing)
  • In re A.C.F., 176 N.C. App. 520 (reasonable-progress evaluated up to the termination hearing)
  • In re Pierce, 146 N.C. App. 641 (must consider changed conditions and probability of repetition when child not in parent’s custody)
  • Ballard v. Board of Education (In re Ballard), 311 N.C. 708 (consider history of neglect and probability of repetition)
  • Quick v. Quick, 305 N.C. 446 (trial court must make specific ultimate findings that flow logically from evidentiary facts)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: In re: Z.D.
Court Name: Court of Appeals of North Carolina
Date Published: Mar 20, 2018
Citations: 258 N.C. App. 441; 812 S.E.2d 668; 258 N.C. 441; COA17-876
Docket Number: COA17-876
Court Abbreviation: N.C. Ct. App.
Log In