midpage
14 Cal.App.5th 486
Cal. Ct. App.
2017

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Twelve-year-old Trever was recorded by the victim’s mother (Kim) while babysitting his 4-year-old cousin Ralph; the audio captured repeated sexual assaults and threats.
  • The prosecutor filed a juvenile wardship petition alleging multiple sexual offenses; the recording was the primary evidence.
  • Trever moved to exclude the surreptitious recording under Penal Code § 632 (requiring all-party consent); the People invoked the § 633.5 exception (one-party consent when recording is reasonably believed to produce evidence of certain crimes).
  • The juvenile court admitted the recording, adopting the vicarious parental-consent doctrine (parent may consent on behalf of a minor if acting in the child’s best interest with an objectively reasonable good-faith belief that recording will produce evidence of an enumerated crime).
  • Trever was found true on several counts and committed to the Division of Juvenile Justice (DJJ); he appealed the recording’s admissibility and his DJJ commitment.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Admissibility of surreptitious recording under §632/§633.5 People: §633.5 permits one-party recordings to obtain evidence of enumerated crimes; parent’s act falls within that exception via vicarious consent Trever: §632 bars recordings absent consent of all parties; Kim was not a party and thus §633.5 exception does not apply The court adopted vicarious parental-consent: a parent may consent for a minor if (1) recording is for obtaining evidence of an enumerated crime and (2) parent has an objectively reasonable good-faith belief it’s in the child’s best interest; recording was admissible
Scope of parental consent doctrine People: doctrine is consistent with legislative purpose and avoids absurdity of criminalizing protective parental conduct Trever: doctrine is not in text of statute; courts cannot judicially add exceptions; potential for misuse Court held statutory language ambiguous as to minors and adopted doctrine, with limits (good faith, objective reasonableness, crime-related purpose)
Truth-in-evidence constitutional defense People argued §632 exclusion may be abrogated by Prop. 8 truth-in-evidence Trever opposed Court did not decide this issue; unnecessary given parental-consent ruling
DJJ commitment abuse of discretion People: DJJ provides more intensive, longer-lasting sex-offender treatment appropriate given offense severity and Trever’s attitudes/risk factors Trever: less restrictive local programs (TYSB/JDF) suffice; DJJ is last resort; lifetime registration harms Court found substantial evidence supporting DJJ (severity, treatment needs, evaluator opinion); no abuse of discretion; commitment affirmed

Key Cases Cited

  • Thompson v. Dulaney, 838 F. Supp. 1535 (D. Utah 1993) (adopted vicarious parental-consent to recording under comparable federal statute)
  • Pollock v. Pollock, 154 F.3d 601 (6th Cir. 1998) (endorsed Thompson and applied vicarious-consent to older minors)
  • People v. Badalamenti, 54 N.E.3d 32 (N.Y. 2016) (New York Court of Appeals adopted vicarious parental-consent and limited it by good-faith, objective-reasonableness standard)
  • State v. Spencer, 737 N.W.2d 124 (Iowa 2007) (interpreted one-party consent exception to permit parental vicarious consent for children)
  • People v. Nazary, 191 Cal. App. 4th 727 (2010) (discussed de novo review of statutory interpretation regarding §632 exceptions)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: In re Trever P.
Court Name: California Court of Appeal
Date Published: Aug 14, 2017
Citations: 14 Cal.App.5th 486; 221 Cal.Rptr.3d 871; F073691
Docket Number: F073691
Court Abbreviation: Cal. Ct. App.
Log In